15 / 17
Feb 2018

I eventually want to package my comics up digitally. and it seems i have a number of options in terms of file format. I also have some older comics i would like to give away

some comics seem to be distributed in .pdf which is fine, but not compatible with dedicated digital comics readers

the other format seems to be .cbr / .cbz which is

which format do you reckon i should go with?

  • created

    Feb '18
  • last reply

    Feb '18
  • 16

    replies

  • 1.9k

    views

  • 4

    users

  • 7

    likes

  • 1

    link

It depends on the platforms you plan on distributing your work through. I'm not sure what "dedicated digital comic reader" you're refering to, but most hosts (like Tapas, Webtoons, Smackjeaves, etc) use .JPG's and . PNG's of varying sizes. If you wanted to use something like Issu, .PDF would probably be your best bet, and then sites like Gumroad & Itch.io let you upload whatever files you want. Check out the guidelines of the platform you're looking to submit to and it will tell you how to submit.

I mean it's not always so cut & dry. PNG's tend to have larger file sizes than JPG's. I've had situations where some of my pages were too large of a file (due to a lot of details and whatnot) for tapas, and so I had to export them as JPG's instead. While it is technically a lower quality image it's not noticeable enough for the average reader to care about (and they have nothing to compare it to on top of that).
There's a time and a place for everything.

well I mean you can always resize your files and keep them as png.. but I've noticed that on the mobile tapas site or on other sites that only accept jpg such as webtoons, (which is why I stopped using it), the quality is all gross and crusty like that of instagram's.

Well of course, however the way Tapas displays pages, if you export PNG's of varying "sizes" (for example if you export at 200dpi vs 300dpi), it will display those pages as different sizes. So in my case, the better option was to export a JPG that had the same resolution/size/whatever, but took up less storage space.

I mean it's not ideal, but I would rather have the occasional slightly-lower-quality image, that basically no one will notice, than having my pages display at random different sizes.

If your .JPG exports are so crusty that you can tell that they're JPG's then you're doing something wrong.

I don't use jpg anymore but when I did, it looked like instagram quality on mobile. you can also notice that on any webtoon comic

Figgure'd I should post an example to showcase what I meant since talking about like, JPGS vs PNG's and their subjective quality VS file size and blablabla can be complicated.

Here's a page of my comic, one of them is a .JPG, the other is a .PNG. Both images have been "compressed" to a size of 940px wide (tapas's maximum file width)
The PNG is 778KB.
The JPG is 752 KB.

I personally can't tell the difference just by looking at them on a screen. It gets different when you're talking about print, in which case, use .PNG's or whatever it is that your printer tells you to use.
Obviously in most circumstances I'm gonna use .PNG's anyways, but occasionally the filesize of the .PNG is too big to upload to tapas at 940px, and so, the smallest compromise is to upload a .jpg instead.

wait is that what you were trying to tell me or am I just dense

My point exactly :V the third one is an example of a .JPG exported "wrong", but even still, if a site had a ridiculously low filesize restriction I would compress my images to that craggly gross point.

(EDIT: You're not dense btw computers are just dumb and confusing.)

thanks guys, not really what i was talking about. I am talking about digital formats for distributing full comic books, like you would buy from comicxology. I use perfect on a tablet to read comics:

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.rookiestudio.perfectviewer&hl=en

i was hoping to find a preferred file format for complete digital comics format.s. seems like pdf is kind of the way to go