I have instantly returned, since there aren't alot of pages to make a clearly defined review on it
I'll say, comic isn't "Scary" per say, but it is shocking.
the aesthetics work, scratch that, they're perfect but it doesn't seem to show any sign of "calming down"
colors occasionally overload the page with a lot going on, which is a shame since the grotesque aesthetic can really give a good punch, but it appears so much and so quickly you really get accustomed to it and it doesn't punch as hard as it should be.
it's also a good thing to really calm down the aesthetic for a bit, because when the horror aesthetic does come up, you can go frigging nuts on it, and its punch will hurt since the pages have been calm for so long, which is ironic since the calm parts building up to the horror is the scariest (Dummy's dummy doesn't rely on blood and relies on the calm and build up for horror, its horror is all about the fact that horrific things certainly exist in the comic, but they don't show up, but hint at its presense, bedtime stories is another good example to look at, in regards to building up to the horror aesthetic, mainly the anthology in first episode)
otherwise, my rating for the first 2 pages are... 5.1/10
trust me, the aesthetics are wonderful, shock value is... shock value... nothing inherently too scary about it, but it definitely has the potential for horror
if you got netflix, I know a netflix original horror movie which you can draw inspiration from, since it uses the exact same horror you seem to be aiming for (don't remember the name), I think it's called "would you rather", where people are forced to pick between 2 evils
an example would be you'd have to be shoved in a bucket of water for 2 minutes, or open a letter with a random punishment ranging from extremely minor to horrifically painful.