28 / 303
Apr 2017

I don't mind the new design at all, in fact I quite like the new rounded letters even if they make things look sorta childish. It's a little more welcoming compared to other webcomic websites. I agree with you on the infinite scrolling though, absolute worst thing.

I get your point that mobile device accessibility is the future and websites are starting to lean towards easy accessibility on mobile devices and the front page is doing that, but as someone mentioned earlier, the scrolling makes it look like you're using the 'desktop view' on a mobile device. I'm on my desktop because I want to use something that's designed for desktop usage, not mobile. I don't use the app because it doesn't have the things I need as a creator without having to take extra steps. Not to mention, not everyone has access to a smartphone or a smartphone thats compatible with the tapas app. So those stuck on a computer have to deal with a less-than-ideal website layout that is better suited to a touch-screen

Also the organization on the front page is all over the place. It's more of a personal peeve but the fact that the order between books, comics, banners, and rows constantly alternating is a headache. That and I haven't seen anyone mention that they like how the front page is organized?

of course im speaking from more of a first read standpoint since I'm not too familiar with web design stuck_out_tongue

Before today we felt like 2nd class, behind the BLs and the gag-a-days, now we're 3rd class behind "the premium" and "the favored". And Daron mentions in the Medium article that the premium stuff is professional . . . so does that make the rest of us unprofessional? This update is a sour surprise and makes next Wednesday's update for our ongoing series difficult to swallow.

0 new subs here we come.

wow i think that's the most disheartened thing I've ever seen you guys post here. Whoof. Never thought I'd see the day.


in other news, i keep instinctively touching the spot where the "forums" button used to be, and keep clicking on "creators" instead

hoo boy the muscle memory is real tho

Oh noes, I like it too. I realize I have the Quicksand Font. I get I think theirs is a mix of Quicksand and Helvetica Nueue if you look at the script, they are beautiful fonts but work better for titles, simple short text, not say a post like some of the ones I do.

For my personal opinion, I don't like the infinite scrolling design many modern websites use. Ideally, I would try to make a desktop version ideal for pointer use and a mobile version ideal for scrolling, but that is actually not very easy. Hence, Tapas's attempt to merge the two (Infinite scrolling is available when reading a comic but you can also click the buttons on the right to move to next page) which is a good idea.

  • As for the organization of the front page, from a user point of view, it's all over the place. You're right. Random banners in between "top picks" is redundant. I'd eliminate those banners all together.
  • From a creator's point of view, this set up is ideal if yo're one of those top creators, as Uzuki has been complaining about. Tapas is really trying to push their new Books so that is twice at the top "Top 10 Books" and "New Books." Unnecessary. If people want the books, they can click on the menu where it says Books. It's right in front of them. For consideration of creators, Recently Updated should be close to the top, then Trending and New+Noteworthy can be closer to the top. Recently Updated or "Fresh" give exposure to the lesser known. I'm relatively "successful" and I believe that is what got attention for my comic in the first place. Staff picks can stay at the bottom. Premium and Top picks (how do they decide these? Same as before?) Don't need to be at the top, or they can make a separate page dedicated to "Top picks." Premium and successful creators don't need as much attention. Attention will automatically flow towards them, so best give light to the lesser known.
  • And from a web design/graphic design point of view, yeah it's cluttered. Hah, right now I'm just bothered by the max width of the body they chose. Too much white space on the sides and this also contributes to the cluttered feel.

Recommendations for the team:
- Fix font
- Keep Fresh close to the top. If Premium and top picks are that important, contribute separate section to them. So the menu can have "Featured | Comics | Books" or something like that. If people want to explore, they can look at New + Noteworthy and Fresh on the front page. If they specifically want "the best," they can go to the Featured tab.
- Fix front page layout. too cluttered. If you want to keep the redundant banners, maybe put them all together at the bottom or top and have no width limit. They really are redundant though. You have Top 10 comics, Top 10 Books, Staff Picks, Trending, AND the banner at the top. Too many on the front page mate.

EDIT: If you see this Michael, sorry, I didn't read the whole page. Wasn't aware some issues such as font were already being addressed. And yeah you're right it does look okay when rendered correctly.

I wanna start off by bringing something positive to the table and say I love that you are finally uniting the brand! This will cause for less confusion between the app and the desktop site, and will make tapastic easier to push on the market, which can benefit everyone on the site! Big creators as well as small ones.

However, that being said...
I feel like what makes tapastic so great is that it's the land of rainbows and unicorns where EVERYONE gets a chance to be seen, and can get much more recognition than anywhere else. I know many of you feel second class to boyslove and gag comics, but speaking as someone who started out only having a horror comic on this site, I know tapastic was a much better place to be seen with difficult-to-sell comics too!
In order to be this loving, great community that gives tons of people the chance to live their dream, i beg you to lift these sections and have them in the following order:
1. POPULAR - gradually, new creators make it into this section all the time. Maybe not the first page of it, but the second page at times and it can give them a huge influx of new readers when that happens! It also helps sustain the healthy reading culture. The top 10 comics simply don't update as freshly and often as the popular section, meaning popular is more sell-able in the land of pageviews and ad revenue. This is crucial both to you as a company and some of us creators, is it not?
2. TRENDING. This was a section where magic happened for so many people. Once upon a time i was a nobody on the site and getting into trending occasionally with my little obscure horror comic made me SO HAPPY. I can't bear to think that creators from this day forth wouldn't get to feel all that joy as the trending section is now buried almost like a shameful badbad that nobody wants around anymore ):
3: FRESH or NEW AND NOTEWORTHY. I prefer this over staff picks. Simply because i am more likely to check out something that in the title implies it's something new and upcoming, rather than something that makes it feel like it might just be staff promoting their friends. I know this isn't the case, but to a new viewer it will feel like it, so titles are important.

Oh, also, i can no longer access the forums on desktop. I use chrome. This is a bit of a problem :c

Concerning the comics published by non-paid creators, the Popular and Trending section should still be on the front page. Otherwise, just occupy a small space of it on the same old area (below the Spotlight section) and put the other premium Tapas comics below of it.

However, that's just my suggestion.

To go back on the overload of premium content at the top of the homepage, might I suggest keeping the popular and trending up top?

Considering newcomers to the website, it might be better to lure them in first with free content before blowing all the scary 'gotta-pay-for-this' comics in their faces. It can be intimidating, especially when the first hundred-or-so comics displayed there are hidden behind a paywall.

First off, I'm still a reader and not a creator.

I like the current font, and it's good that the app and desktop version are being unified, because them being so different is a bit confusing. The site in general comes off as fresh, clean, and professional. But there is one thing I don't agree with:

The initial screen and first "scrolls" are premium, app-only content. As a reader, this is a turn-off in three ways:

  1. I'm on desktop, and I need to go to the app to access these comics? I'm on desktop for a reason: big screen, access to a real keyboard for typing replies, doing other stuff as well as reading comics.
  2. Everything is paid content - let's face it, people love free stuff, and stuffing our faces with free comics is probably the reason most come here. I'm pretty sure that the vast majority of readers will at most want to buy into one or two comics, and the rest of the time they're around for the free ones. If they're not seeing any free content at first glance, they will assume it's only paid content.
  3. The independent, free comics are gone? The not-promoted-or-officially-endorsed comics are pushed so far down that they simply aren't visible unless you scroll pretty far, and even then it's not clear that they're actually free. The site comes off as exclusively curated as opposed to free creation - which IMO is not as attractive.

To sum it up, I think it would be beneficial to both the site and the users to show both premium and free comics on the top screen, because readers will be more inclined to get invested into tapastic if they can get more out of it than the few series they pay for! As this article succinctly points out: It's better to convert 5% of 2 million visitors than 50% of 100'000 visitors, and you will be getting more visitors with prominent free content. And you'll have more creators on tapastic - which all funnel more people to the site through their promoting their own comic.

I think that it really comes down to that there are two directions for Tapas/tic to go: Aim for the small number of well-paying readers and make the site focused on curated pay-content (reader-focused site), or promote the forums and the free content and have premiums as a bonus (creator-inclusive site). Both are legit business models, but if the former is what you're aiming for, which it looks like right now, I think we'd appreciate a clear statement on it, because up until recently, Tap seemed to be the second model and many creators are feeling cheated right now. I also do not feel terribly compelled to upload my upcoming comic to tapastic anymore, simply because I don't think it stands a snowflake's chance in Sahara in getting noticed.

I should add that I feel the same about the app. I come for the free comics, and it's alienating to be bombarded with all this premium content and ads.

EDIT:

I somehow completely missed this on my first readthrough. Good to know. I'll still leave my post as-is because there might be something of interest to you in it anyway.

Edit2: I don't mind the font much, but when typing a reply to a comic it feels redundant to bolden the text.

So, in summary, people don't hate the premium comics but the majority of tapastic creators and readers are here to produce and read free content and we would all prefer for that to be promoted highest on the page, right below the spotlight, where it previously was. With this many people all agreeing on the same thing (I've had people in my audience express this to me too, so there's even more people agreeing with this than you see speaking up about it here), i think tapas as a brand would suffer horribly if they refuse to change it.

However some people seem a little grumpy and I should say that I honestly don't feel like tapas did this on purpose or to alienate us. The way this looks right now, the new desktop look is a work in progress. They basically translated all the app's coded frontpage over to the desktop and plopped it on top of the current one, and it should be an easy fix to just move the popular and trending sections up. I doubt they'll ignore us.

We believe in you, tapas staff!! Bring the promotion of free content creators and small creators back! OAO/

Yes, Thank you. I hope this can roll out soon, this causes me to lose much of my interest in Tapastic, despite the already better UI.

I'm already miserable and struggling enough as I am after recovering from an extremely long creative slump, but to push independent creators all the way to the bottom of the page? I truly hope that this isn't an omen for the potential terror that is to come, I mean the world in itself is already falling into a pit of degeneracy.

Please reconsider the layout of the front page, especially how independent creators are being presented. I understand the need for bucks, so I'm okay with having premium comics on the front page, but making practically the entire thing dedicated to premium comics diminishes the little hope for my work I already have.

3

This might be a bug or something, but I don't know, but how do I add a title?
I can't post an episode because I can't add a title, but the bar is gone?

@Chopythes Oh my god so it's like REALLY hard to tell but there's a place to type it near the episode number. Where the word "Title" is grayed out.

OMG THANK YOU!
I'm so used to it looking like before, I didn't even think about clicking that!
Thank you for letting me know!

Forums is at the very bottom of the page. Inconvenient as all hell but it's there. I mentioned it in my wall of text.

No, I know that, but using that link I just get the error of the site not responding. I had to download firefox just to be able to open the forums now because chrome wouldn't do it. And yes, I did clean my cache first to check. Didn't help.

OK Guys. in light of the recent events, I wanted to see some of the interviews that was conducted in Tapas/tic's name and head of the company, Mr. Chang Kim.

According to several articles, Tapas/tic is trying to incorporate the Korean Webtoon system in the western market. As Mr. Chang Kim who was working in Google came across Korean webtoon and wanted to do something in it. This is a fact that was in several articles in the past.

As for where the Site is heading now, I thought it would help for me to analyze and share the directions and what was said regarding it



http://platum.kr/archives/721192

  • This 2016 December articles states how bringing in the Korean content from Korean sites (namely 'They say I was born as a king's Daughter, Adonis, etc contracted with Podotree, a subsidiary to the Korean company Kakao) has increased their monetization amount of 48% per month since its implementation in May of 2016. In November, it tripled that of Octorber.

  • The Article also suggests that its transformation from comic to text book app has given them a huge boost in the app store (ranking among 3~10) which they plan to do more of and has.

Tl;dr - So from this, we could tell that the platform's change was warranted to go towards monetizing contents and going towards book than comic's direction. which is further proven by the most recent interview





  • In this article which came out in april of 2017 (so a couple of weeks ago), which is titled "On the opposite ground of Marvel; aiming towards female targetted romance webtoon"

  • This one goes a little more detail in the CEO's plan where he prefers 'Contents with possibilities of adaptations such as movies' for growth of the site. The article also suggests that he hopes to create a 'webtoon' like 'Iron man' who are adapted from comics to games, movies and other mediums

-The article suggests that his primary goal of 'spreading webtoon in the US market' has met success. It says that he spent the first year in explaining the concept of webtoon and finding creators capable of making webtoons.

  • It goes on to say how much tapas/tic has grown as a platform, obtaining over 21K professionals and non-professional creators with 500K chapters published, With average monthly visitor of 1.3Million

  • CEO Kim goes on to explains the secret behind its growth as 'going the opposite direction from Marvel and DC' While the two companies make male targeted contents like Avengers, Batman and other hero contents, Tapas focuses on female targeted contents like romance and fantasy. It's also easier to adapt it into other forms which allows the content to have various gates in growth. He also states that there has been increased talks from Hollywood, netflix, amazon and other platforms in regards to finding original materials for adaptations.

  • He ends the interview by saying that finding out about Korean webtoon allowed me to venture into this directions. The sparkling fresh ideas of Korea can meet a market hundred times bigger when it's brought to US

Tl;dr - Tapas/tic's main goal was to work with and from the Korean webtoon system. Focusing Female targeted contents to generate more opportunities. Wishes to create or own a big IP that is like the Iron man




In conclusion, Tapas/tic's changes and directions do seem pretty clear once you read these interviews (Although not in English). While I feel that this could've been communicated with the creators here, it does seem like the starting point and the future of the site was set from a while ago.

I really hope they're not gonna put their focus on premium content. Most members are here under the assumption that it's a free content website for individual creators firsthand, and premium content second. Or third. Or tenth.

I have faith in tapastic, but IF this turns out to be their intentions it will ruin every single thing that's good about the site.

THAT BEING SAID, MICHAELSON ALREADY SAID THEY WERE GOING TO SURFACE THE NON PREMIUM CONTENT COMICS.

THIS ISN'T EVEN A DISCUSSION. THEY'VE ALREADY CLEARLY STATED THEY WILL DO THIS AND THAT THEY ARE ONLY EXPANDING INTO MORE PREMIUM CONTENT. NOT FOCUSING ON IT.

Tapastic aren't some terrorists out to get us. They're business partners o_o