1 / 4
Sep 2022

This thread is to share and discuss:

  • Tips you have for creating 'good' cover art, and what that means.
  • Share your cover to get feedback or just for fun!
  • Provide feedback on other people's cover art.
  • What tools do you use to make your art? What was your artistic vision?

Quick rule: If you are posting your cover to request feedback please explicitly say that. If a person has not asked, then don't give it.

How to ask for feedback
Placing my research hat on for a moment to give some general advice on how to get good "user insights" when asking for feedback: The way you ask for feedback or opinions matters. If the questions is too open it's really easy for people to focus on whether they personally like something. This can create two possible issues:

  1. They may not be your target audience, so their personal taste may not be relevant.
  2. Most of us are people pleasers to some extent, and if you ask something like "is this good?" people can be pretty quick to say "yes" without giving anything useful. This is more of an issue in person though than online (especially with friends or family).

If you're asking for feedback ask yourself why. What do you want to find out? Then form a question from there.

Examples you can use

If you want to know whether the cover represents the story well enough try:

"What do you think this story might be about?"
"What kind of setting or genre might it have?"
"How does this cover make you feel?"
"What kind of tone do you think this story has?"

If you want to know whether it looks good as a piece of graphic design, you could ask that directly. But if you're having trouble getting useful info you could probe with some more practical prompts such as:

"What does the title say?"
"What do the images on my cover look like to you?"
"If you saw this in a bookstore would you pick it up?"

^ You also might want to try these ones with small versions of the cover (scaled down to the tapas size used on mobile).

This isn't to say any specific thing is right or wrong for the design itself, just some ideas for how to get useful information out of people. Especially people outside of this sub who may be less familiar with thinking about what goes into a cover design. Hope it helps!

Anyway share away :slight_smile: and feel free to link to your story.

  • created

    Sep '22
  • last reply

    Oct '22
  • 3

    replies

  • 461

    views

  • 3

    users

  • 5

    likes

  • 3

    links

Starting for my own thread, this is the cover I made for a story I've just started. I made it in canva using free assets, which meant that if I was using imagery I needed to use stuff that was a bit more symbolic or abstract.

So far I've found creating cover art to be really motivating for me. It makes it feel more official, and ready to be shared/updated. I haven't posted much (only 1 chapter plus a second scheduled) so we'll see how long that feeling lasts though!

I'm not a massive fan of doing it (For aesthetic reasons) but I added the "GL" tag for marketing reasons. When I'm browsing it's something I look out for, mainly because it is in my experience a bit harder to find a solid lesbian story compared to BL.

I'd be happy to hear feedback if anyone wanted to give any, in particular I'd like to ask you the following questions:

  • What kind of tone do you think my story has from this cover image?
  • What genre(s) do you think it will be?

Might be worth mentioning that I consider the title itself to be part of the cover so don't feel like you have to ignore what the actual title says.

Thanks in advance! And happy sharing.

Sharing would be a bit of fun...here's mine:

My story is a spiritual sequel to an anime called Re:Creators, and so the cover art is very deliberately harkening back to it - this poster, in particular: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:ReCreators_Main_Visual.jpeg2

So...should I debut the cover art for the sequel that starts going live on December 2nd? It is done...

Sure, why not?

And now, time for bed.

1 month later

closed Oct 3, '22

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.