Favorite types of feedback?

[LCT_m_a_d]

I like any response that reminds me that a real person wrote it. Doesnt matter if it's a critique, complaint, or personal anecdote. As long as it's a personal interaction, it makes me happy that my art helps drive that connection.

[TheOne]

I like when people ask questions. It tells me that they actually read my writing, and it also tells me that they are interested in knowing more about it.

[DokiDokiTsuna]

I think I like it best when commenters interact with each other and theorize, about the characters or about what I as the author might do next. Even if their ideas are way off the mark, it's just nice to see that someone can hold an opinion about my work AND care enough to share it with another person.

[sarrowsmith10]

I like any response that reminds me that a real person wrote it. Doesnt matter if it's a critique, complaint, or personal anecdote. As long as it's a personal interaction, it makes me happy that my art helps drive that connection.

This. Really any sort of comment that isn't straight up rude is good for me. Deep questions.. simple one word replies. The whole spectrum is good.

[yansusu]

I also love comments on the story itself like what people think of what just happened or what might happen. The same with characters. It's just so fun to see readers going 'I want to hug this character! He's so precious!', then turn around and come up with methods of torture for somebody else

[jensrichard77]

I love love love when a reader can comment on something that needs a full understanding of my universe.
Imagen that the hard work actually is understood by someone!

[GesuGesu]

I love the ones that hurt my feelings. Feed me to the wolves lol. I don't need nice words.

[ninjashira]

My favorite type of feedback is honestly anything that can instigate a conversation or necessitate a response. Obviously I like and appreciate when someone says, "I love your comic!" But it doesn't leave much for me to respond to, aside from, "Thanks I'm glad you like it." Anything that provokes conversation is stellar in my book, because it gives me something to respond to.

[LCT_m_a_d]

You're a winner to me, no matter what!

[rmdooley]

I enjoy witty comments (and my readership is hilarious) but I find comments on the characters, plot, what the readers like or expect are the most useful.

And whenever a reader leaves an emotional reaction following a tense scene, that makes my week

[beta1042]

I really enjoy watching my readers have discussions with eachother and theorize about the story itself. Or to run thoughts back and forth about the characters and why they think the characters are behaving how they did.

[penguininvasion]

I enjoy feedback that helps me out because I don't get much of it. ^_^

Saying, "it's good" or "it's bad" doesn't help me, but asking questions or pointing out flaws in logic is super helpful! I'm usually pretty good about catching my grammar mistakes and inconsistencies (hair color, body position, etc) but not really about large leaps in logic and the like.

[KoreanTacos]

I like when my readers can make me laugh instead.

[Hodge]

If its a comment from a readers I'll take anything lol, but comments that show they are invested in the story are heartwarming. More than being told the art is great or what not, I like to see readers connected with characters.

If its feedback like a critique or from an editor, I want it to be brutally honest.
Ravage me. ᴮᵘᵗ ᵖʳᵃᶦˢᵉ ᵐᵉ ʷʰᵉⁿ ᴵ ᵈᵒ ˢᵒᵐᵉᵗʰᶦⁿᵍ ʷᵉˡˡ ᵖˡᶻ

[Tamachii]

Fanfic, artwork of your characters, even cosplay (if you're lucky)
In short, inspiring another person to create.

[keii4ii]

Comments that let me know "this person really gets what I'm trying to do." With Heart of Keol, that tends to be people commenting on what they read between the lines, unspoken thoughts/feelings of the characters, etc. Could be as simple as "ohhhh I see, this is a comic about feelings and tenderness! Not about epic conspiracy or cool fights!"

[Drewbie]

On one hand I love comments that are are people speculating how the story is going yet when I read that, it make it so hard for me because like I want to reply but I don't want to spoil anything for the readers and say a "yes or no" aIso like comments that are saying things like they about a character or a certain scene. Specifics always help.

[ivanskilling]

Like many people have said, I love comments about the story, the characters, and the world I've built!
I like to know what my readers think and feel when they read my works.

Critiques and thoughts about my works are also very much appreciated! I'm always interested in how to improve my writing.

[Luminosophy]

Mostly when people pick up the intent behind something, makes me feel like I achieved what I set out to do. : >

[IxPhoen]

I usually only share my fiction with friends, so I don't have experience with outside feedback yet.

With that said: My brain tends to default to "Well, of course they're going to say something nice. It's like an obligatory friendship reaction!" The only response that gets past "pfft, you're just saying that. I know I'm unworthy," is when they engage with the story context or react on a philosophical level.

Even if they end up not talking about the story itself but some topic that the characters brought to mind, the fact that their reaction started a conversation is what matters. It's a special feeling.

@Tamachii -- Fan-response art of any kind would be so much fun!