20 / 52
Feb 2024

My writing has been said to betray a lack of real life experience and of the real complexities of a person, and that I should get a sense of realistic person behavior. How do I make that so? The person who said it mentioned college but most of my college time is just doing class stuff which indicates nothing about human behavior and how to write it properly, especially not the specific character i’m writing who I don’t think any real person acts like, the same way no one genuinely acts like spongebob squarepants or sonic the hedgehog.

What did you do as a writer to get primary source as to how a real person behaves and how did that change the way you write your characters?

  • created

    Feb '24
  • last reply

    Feb '24
  • 51

    replies

  • 2.2k

    views

  • 1

    user

  • 60

    likes

  • 2

    links

I mean, aren't you a person? Don't you know people? Friends, family etc? Look, I know you are on the spectrum so this is probably more difficult for you than someone who isn't. But this isn't something I feel you can really teach, you use your own lived experiences as building blocks for your characters.

<<< It's me, hi, I'm the problem it's me!

Hello again, it is the source of the question being asked. Again.

The answer is... People watching. If you are spending time in class and than no time just hanging around on campus you're not gonna observe anything.

Once again, broad advice I've given you has been chipped away and narrowed down to a hyper-specific set of parameters I didn't mean.

Go out, get friends, people watch, talk to people and listen to them. That is how you learn about people if you pay attention. Any kind of person.

If you feel you know people well enough than the character is fine. As I've said time and time again anything I've said it an opinion.

You can't go out and 'people watch' when it comes to creating a character whose behavior is shaped by their trauma.

It's one thing if they're a teen or college age and you need the basics - sitting in a cafeteria or cafe on campus and observing like a sketch artist, defintely works - but trauma-centric behaviors cannot be learned ethically (you'd have to join a support group under the guise of said trauma to really people watch those with it.)

You can comb over case studies, pay attention to how they feel and what they're explaining. Articles and books with case studies are best thing to study how trauma manifests in everyday sociality.

As I've said, this was basic advice. Not trauma specific. People are still people outside of their trauma even if it can take up are large part of their person, especially if untreated and processed.

Unfortunately, the extensive context of this conversation is larger than what being presented here and months of back and forth at this point.

I've already explain in private messages that he should figure out what the specifc trauma the character is experiencing is and to look at scientific articles about it to decide what would fit the character best. He did not find that advice helpful or did not know how to go about doing it.

My advice is to just write the story. It doesn't matter if it's bad. If Michael Bay can get an audience, so can you

Watch interviews and documentaries. I'm working on a story rn starring an autistic lead, as I'm not autistic, I'm watching videos on ASD, interviews with autistic people, xyz.

The truth is, you can't experience everything, so you'll probably have to write some things you don't know about, thanks to the internet though, that's very possible. An annoying sense of humor might be hard to research as everyone has a different opinion on that, but you could look up videos on annoying things siblings do, because most people have those ideas in common, and translate that over to you character. As far as trauma is concerned, there are a whole lot of interviews, videos and documentaries on these things, but be forewarned that it might be very hard on YOU emotionally, to watch these.

I don't think anyone can 100% capture a real person's trauma and life experiences unless they lived through it or experienced something similar (i.e. a soldier who never had combat experience can only relate as far as deployment and basic training is concerned when talking to another soldier who was wounded in battle).

But like others said, the best you can do is immerse yourself into the subject matter at hand via books, videos, etc on the subject matter. Research research research... and if it is still not accurate oh well... at least you tried

I think it’s that what my mom or little brothers do around the house and what people do in class just doesn’t give me a sense of how a 19 year old or anyone with trauma would realistically behave, or even how someone else’s mom or little brother would realistically behave. I guess if I went out more I’d be able to osmosis an idea of human behavior but I don’t think that would allow me to mold that into the specific behavior of one person.

Am I interpreting the concept wrong? I feel like I am.

I wasn’t ever not writing it. I just wrote a scene and a half for this exact character yesterday, and I think it was a good scene. Today i’ll write more and before february fifth I will have a proper third draft of my story.

I looked at those sources and then more stuff after that, also I understand that the point of studying other people is not so that you can write trauma. I just thought I should explain the context behind this, because when I try to separate a question from the exact reason i’m asking everyone is demanding the story and are mad that I’m not giving the exact context even when it’s not important.

Well i’m dropped off to one class and when that class is done my parents are waiting outside to pick me up and drive me home again.

What do you mean by hyper specific parameters? I’m sorry if I missed something, I didn’t think your advice was a singleminded machine latched to one tiny spot of the writing landscape.

When you say specific trauma do you mean there should be a specific medical diagnosis he can be given? Or do you mean something else?

Josh enough. Just enough please. We have gone over this and over this. This is a conversation we had weeks ago when I linked the PTSD article. Just write the draft, make the comic and move onto the next thing. You're in school, just focus on that right now.

I don’t have plans to be making the comic anytime this year. Instead i’ll be drawing and writing and gaining experience with this stuff so I can make sure i’m up to task before I finish the story draft. Before the fifth I will finish the draft, for the rest of february I will work on writing short story drafts (and catching up on that trauma research), and after that I will go back go my comic script and novel with fresh eyes the perspective of a beta reader, and research, and edit it again. Then I am going to make second drafts of all those short stories, then i’m doing a second preptober so I can basically do nanowrimo in june. There will be a bunch of mini comic things and maybe a real comic but a small one, then I’ll start the comic sometime next year.

Try writing something you know about for starters :sip: you will spend all time procrastinating over stuff you have no idea how to do and there's small chance you will do it well from the first attempt, especially if you're not putting any research in it.

Even things I know I still don’t feel confident writing. Like I wrote about two gay autistic characters and still didn’t quite get where I was going with it or how to do it right. So I did research into the subject.

You get life experience from living life. There isn't a way to cheat time. Just like if you haven't been a police officer for 20 years, you won't have 20 years of policing experience.

You suck at writing people because you don't understand people.

How do you understand people? Be a person. Get a job. Get fired. Take public transport. Travel. Make friends. Lose friends. Fall in love. Cheat on someone. Get cheated on.

You know the answer, why are we discussing this?

Sorry. It’s just that i’m home all day aside from a few hours of class per week, and don’t have friends or anything, so this is kind of a major change.

Joshi boy,
shouldn't you focus more on your studies? I mean having an education and getting a decent job from it seems kinda~ important.:grimacing:

(Also, did you do some roleplaying? Like BEING that character and think how they would act in the situation?)

My studies are fine right now, and I have less assignments to do this week than there are days of the week.

Do you have any to recommend? Like what documentaries and interviews did you look at, and do you know any that would apply to thinks like CPTSD.

And I am. There are multiple videos on the subject in my tabs. I'm just asking for more recommendations so I can see as much as possible on the subject.

No. Did you say to? I don't remember it and I can't find it.

Do people have to tell you to do this? When writing, don't you automatically imagine yourself in the proverbial skin of the character, try to think and act like they do?

No I'm asking because it sounded like he mentioned it before.

There's all sorts of discords and message boards out there. Even the NEET Hikikomoris manage to get some form of online community going on. Been in those spaces.

All they talk about is anime, video games, and random memes (90% of the time) the occasional deep discussions on philosophy and the meaning of life (10%)... and the occasional rant on how much life sucks and it spirals into nihilism, efilism, anti natalism, and atheism, then the occasional Christian, Muslim, or Buddhist gets banned or voluntarily leaves.

Being alone with little to no friends ain't so bad. More time to meditate, enjoy nature, and draw my webtoon.

I never said that. Cause I thought it was kinda obvious since most of us do it. And personally, I don't like to respond to every thread you make since it's either the same question different wording or step by step process. And I hate repetition. Joshi boy just do it. You don't need us to tell you what you have to do nor that we should hold your hand during your progress.
Just do your thing, see what works, where to improve and work on the next thing. That's why trial and error exist. Nobody is perfect.

I think a lot of things are obvious only for it to turn out that they need explaining or to just not be true at all, and all those times i'm the wrong one.

I have never heard of a writer roleplaying as their character to make them do a thing, no matter which space I went to for writing advice, including a space for DND roleplayers. Even the Roleplayers never told me to roleplay as my character. Why would it be obvious?

You are hyperfixitating on the word "roleplay" and taking what he said way too literal.

It's this overly literal way you approach what people say and do that's at the very root of your struggles as a writer and storyteller. How can you hope to prortray a chaacter as a believable person, when you don't have a grasp on basic human behavior. And no, this isn't something you can teach yourself by watching a youtube video or observing some guy in a bar. This is a fundamental sense of empathy you just seem to kinda lack or at least struggle with greatly.

This is lickely due to you being on the spectrum, I get it, it's hard. But you aren't gonna logic your way out of this, it's just something you gotta feel. your constant stream of questions isn't gonna help you here, frankly, I doubt any form of outside help will. It's an inward journey you gotta take, better understand yourself, because you can start to understand others and write characters as real believable people.

And before you ask, no, no one here is gonna be able to really effectively help you with that, it's all up to YOU. The only outside help you can really get is with a professional psychologist (which I really doubt any of us here are.)

(post withdrawn by author, will be automatically deleted in 24 hours unless flagged)

So you just meant trying to think like them? Well that's just... what a writer does... try to get in their characters head and think of what they'd do, and i've done that. I don't see how any writer doesn't do it. I would never describe that as roleplay, it just is what writing is when you care about your characters.

It's imagining. You imagine what your character will do in this or that situation, trying to put yourself in their shoes. The same as roleplaying, maybe a bit less acting. Or not, you decide. You can literally roleplay all the characters in your book writing dialogue as you imagine yourself being them if it helps.

Sorry about that post I should have waited for a second instead of reacting so quickly. I was hoping I had deleted it before you got to see it.

Now you're just unnecessarily harsh on yourself. Look. I assumed that you knew it since it is common among artists and writers alike. You didn't knew it and that's okay. Nobody is giving you lip for that. Heck, I admit I don't know basic cooking stuff or other stuff as well that is commonly known and that doesn't let me down to still try it. If somebody is trying to tell you something it isn't meant in bad faith and they just let you know that you don't have the same problem again. You learn something new every day.

Okay. I'm calling BS on that point. That's why I said it is obvious since that is what a writer does. Especially in DND which is the core element of the game. Or do you think we just make characters like:

We make the characters based on tropes or other characters we've seen, maybe add a little bit of us for extra flavor to spice things up, and have our original creation that way.