I'll rate your comic/novel cover

[Paul_Tromba]

4.5/5

Looks pretty good and there's little to no unused space. I am lowering a half point for lacking your author name but it is good otherwise.

[Paul_Tromba]

4.5/5

This is perfect in its spacing, palette, use of shades, and framing. It does lack your author name though so I am demoting half a point from it. Love the title font!

[susutaru]

Hey, if you like to evaluate my Cover too?

[Tursastheeternal]

Here's my individual chapter covers:

[skullforceagents]

What do you think of my cover?

[dayworks]

Ok I'm game.

[animamundisoulworld]

Its a little old but the Idea was supposed to be Surreal with a hidden meaning or two.
I have an idea for a new one with people that I hope to make by the next month. @Paul_Tromba

[kwanchequanche]

Sure! I'll share the version with my watermark.

Thank you, have a lovely day/night ahead!

[Paul_Tromba]

So sorry for the late reply. Work irl has been crazy the past few weeks.

cover 1
4.5/5
Love the title, font, spacing, the art, framing, color palette, and use of background space! The art is also really cute. You can even see the desire, love, and concern they have in their expressions! Would even sell this as a poster. I will denote a point because of the lack of an author's name, but that is more personal.

cover 2
4.4/5
This one is like the first, where I can praise everything I did in the first. The lighting is a bit much for me personally, but I don't think it is worth denoting a point for.

cover 3
3/5
This is good for the title, font, placement, framing, and art. Though the color palette feels more bland along with the background. Still love the art!

[abigaillmartin]

I’m just gonna…

Since they’re now in the lineup of my works

[Paul_Tromba]

cover
4/5
loving the art. the framing of the falling or drowning is great! The background and lighting are phenomenal too. I love that you included your author name on the cover and I love the title font. The title placement is a bit odd to me as I feel like there is too much open space at the top. Loving the volume number as well!

banner
5/5
This is amazing storytelling! It intrigue and attracts people to a story with just the art alone.

[Cafezal]

What about mine?

The third chapter is already online!

Read BLACK SHEEP | Tapas Web Community

[rewritteninthestars]

Here is my cover for your consideration:

I have a few qualms with it myself, and I reuse it for various different sites by cropping it in different ways, which might make its composition a bit questionable lol. I'm curious to see thoughts on it, though, so that I know what to improve on in the future if I feel the need to draw a new one.

[The_Chosen_Z]

[blitz_kreed]

Cover and Banner for my Series Aurexis which I'm uploading on Tapas

[Paul_Tromba]

Cover
3.8/5

The title is well placed on the cover, but either the font or the alignment feels off to me. I can't quite place exactly which would fix the eye appeal to me. Loving the art and the detail! Love the Author's name at the bottom as well! The background is okay, but it feels a bit empty.

Banner
5/5
Everything about this is perfect! It tells a story, and everything fits without unused space. Good Job!

[Paul_Tromba]

Cover
4.5/5
Love the art. The framing is great! why do the eyes follow me like an old facial image of Pope Benedict XVI? The title font and effects are great. Love the placement. Denoting a point for lack of author's name.

Banner
5/5
Again with the eyes! Why do they follow me! Do I need to lock my doors?

[Paul_Tromba]

4.5/5
What the actual backwoods hell is that! Denoting a point for lack of the Author's name, but this is still awesome! I would just have that as a poster in my room or some background art for my PC.

[shriraa.sha]

Thank you so much for the feedback! I've been looking into how to improve, even if its minor adjustments so this means a lot!

[Paul_Tromba]

Of course. I hope this helps as much as my humble opinion can!