To respond to OP's original question- I'm curious why you would think these examples are, or might be viewed as transphobic?
I have difficulty judging the first case- largely because of the language barrier- but the over-the-top performance reads to me as a sort of drag queen cabaret? If the intention here is to actually depict trans women (that doesn't appear to be the case?) then I can absolutely see how this would be transphobic for more or less equating trans women with drag queens. If not- it just reads as drag show style comedy. However, there may be cultural elements at play here that I simply don't have the background to understand.
The second case I feel I can speak on with a little more confidence, and so with confidence, I think "Not, not really."
It's actually a pretty interesting case, since- (spoilers, I guess, for those who want to watch it for themselves for the first time)- it involves forced sexual reassignment surgery on a cisgender person? The character in question is most definitely upset about this though. If anything, it seems to me that a film depicting or suggesting that a cisgender person goes through something akin to gender dysphoria if/when they are forced to live as the gender they don't identify with is actually affirming of transgender experiences. The cisgender character is essentially being put in the position of "walking in the shoes" of a transgender person in a brutal, horrifying way (although in this case, there's definitely more levels of awful on top of that, not the least of which is being forced to impersonate your kidnapper's wife O_o).
I've seen a few movies that tackle the idea of a cisgender person being forced to undergo sexual reassignment surgery. In general, I think this can actually be explored in an interesting way that is still respectful of transgender people's experiences. Where it crosses the line and become explicitly transphobic, in my humble opinion- is if either A) the character proceeds to develop into some kind of caricature embodying all the nastiest stereotypes about transgender people (e.g. a particular unfortunate example I once saw was a movie in which the "twist" is that a seemingly "male" character is actually a cisgender woman who forced a grisly operation and alternate identity on herself as a way to overcome sexual trauma, only to become a manipulative psychopath- this, believe it or not, is a real stereotype about transgender men that has evolved from certain kinds of trans-exclusionary feminist discourse) or B) it's played entirely for laughs (I've seen this done a couple of times in "comedies" where straight, cisgender men are forced to undergo sex reassignment surgeries, only to go on and use this as an excuse to be predatory towards women- thus perpetuating the same damaging narrative at the core of the good old public bathroom policy debate)
But regardless of whether or not the treatment of the subject matter is transphobic- the truly sad thing is that there are more movies like that in existence than there are movies that even attempt to depict actual transgender characters.
Signed,
A somewhat salty transgender person. x')
P.S. This is one's person's opinion of course. I don't speak for every transgender person and never will. And I also know that without other cues to back it up, writing in a forum can across as aggressive- so just to be clear, I totally don't mean my comments in an aggressive or combative way at all. And I do think there's a lot of room for discussion here.
