I think it's OK. There is some stuff I like and other stuff I don't.
I think I appreciate it mostly because it's made by an indie studio. I can see how that could be inspiring to up and coming creators. I think some of the flaws in the writing is sort of a side effect of indie work. But the hardwork and effort is there.
I am not part of the fandom, which might be for the best. I hear it's a bit intense which is not my cup of tea.