1 / 47
Jul 2017

Heeey <3 I am wondering about webcomic creators who wanted some feedback and I thought maybe I wil host a comment exchange! Just sign up your name here with your webcomic and I will assign you randomly to a webcomic and you need to comment to at least 5 pages of their webcomic. Constructive feedback, no comments only like "Looks cool!" "Good job!" I don't have a series, so you'll get comments for free from me! If you hadn't got a comment from your assigned commenter, I will do it.

Participants
1. Lisha - Backup
2 Michelle - https://tapas.io/series/Centralia2050
3 Spudfuzz - https://tapas.io/episode/723933
4 azureXtwilight - https://tapas.io/series/ReSet1
5 keii4ii - http://tapas.io/series/keol
6 punkarsenic - https://tapas.io/series/TWAW
7 wumblebumarts - https://tapas.io/series/flirtingwithdeath1
8. insomniascrawl - https://tapas.io/series/Semi-Super
9. cleo_san - https://tapas.io/series/Remembermanga
10. Sakebiensei - https://tapas.io/series/Lets-make-tomorrow-today
11. kanugane - https://tapas.io/series/Tenebres
12. shaylafarey5 - https://m.tapas.io/episode/112588
13. CaptnHeroic - https://tapas.io/series/Adventures-with-Captn-Heroic
14 mbdelgados - https://tapas.io/series/Things-to-do-instead-of-studying

Rules
- I will link you your assigned comic in 3 DAYS
- Comment in at least FIVE PAGES of their comic, in 5 DAYS after I message you
- You can praise or offer criticism, just be polite! NO SHORT COMMENT. BE CIVIL, ALSO!
.
.
.

  • created

    Jul '17
  • last reply

    Jan '18
  • 46

    replies

  • 4.8k

    views

  • 18

    users

  • 42

    likes

  • 18

    links

Oh, I like giving feedback and longer comments! :> I'll give it a shot. My comic is here:

Hey I'm totally down for this, great idea!

Awesome idea! I'm down! Do we have some kind of deadline?

@Michelle @spudfuzz @azureXtwilight added you three and added some rules!

Rules
- I will link you your assigned comic in 3 DAYS
- Comment in at least FIVE PAGES of their comic, in 5 DAYS after I message you
- NO SHORT COMMENT. BE CIVIL, ALSO!

Come and join!

Can you give people like 5 days to comment, in case they have a really intense work schedule this/that week? Or would that be a "let us know if you need a couple more days" kinda thing?

I'll also join!

this sounds cool! i might be slow on my commenting bc my work load is massive right now, but i wanna be part of this

Let's do iiiiiiiiiit!!!

I'm game Here's my comic.

@wumblebumarts @insomniascrawl @punkarsenic : Added you to the list!

Also I was thinking, should there some kind of penalty for those who doesn't meet their ends? I will personally cover for them since I love commenting, but there should be a slight penalty. Maybe have the comments removed from their page when they don't do their end over a week and no reply to me?

Count me in! <3 I hope I'll find some new awesome comics to add to my reading list! X3

Here's mine:

Sounds neat, but give me time to read them. I spend 90% at work, mostly with no internet(I'm on a ship)

Hi,
I am looking for feedback but at the moment I don't have a lot of time to comment and read a lot.

I would be happy to do some in around 2 weeks though!~

my comic :

If this is going to be a recurring thing with round 2, 3, etc., then maybe there should be a naughty list for people who don't deliver their part as promised? They would be banned from participating in future rounds.

Question, by "constructive" do you include constructive criticism?

Added the new participants to the list!

@shaylafarley5 : You forgot to include your comic link? :grin:

@keii4ii I haven't thought about another round, maybe I will consider if this one goes well?

Yes, of course!

All right! Keep submissions in! I will close it in two more days!