On a more serious note, I'd have to say the first Life is Strange.
I could go write a whole essay on why (in fact, I seem to remember doing something like that), but it all boils down to Chloe's character. I personally don't really understand how she resonated with so many people, and I don't like how the game constantly, at every turn presumes the player likes her as much as the main character Especially since most of the things she does effectively do just the opposite.
There's a fair other things that kind of irk me about it, but that's probably my biggest issue.
As always, though, if people liked her and the game -- fair's fair. I don't see it, but I'm glad you enjoyed it.