1 / 17
Jan 2019

So recently I've been looking into Instagram stories and suddenly an advertisement from WebNovel popped up

I don't watch much anime, but I know it is Lelouch and CC from Code Geass. That means it's a fanart by some artist out there, and is not meant for this advertisement.

I try to crosscheck it using TinEye and found the exact image in danbooru donmai, which I traced it into a Pixiv account

The artist's name is creayus/嵐月

Here's link to original art:

And it is clearly said in the artist's ToS they don't allow it for commercial use.

I tried to email the artist about this in broken Japanese (Google translate) and attach the screenshot of the ads, but it's keep getting queued :sob: that I don't know if I can't reach them. I don't have Twitter or Pixiv account.

My question is, what can us and the artist do to take down the ad even if the artist is notified? Since the ad only appears once out of the blue that the screenshot is only proof. Considering the fact Instagram is known to be very lenient about art theft, unfortunately :sweat:

It makes me pissed off when they deliberately use art of foreign artist who don't speak English (the artist said themselves) to advertise their website and service, that they're less likely to notice and defend themselves. I meant WebNovel is a legit website; if they can gain revenue from their contents and pay Instagram for ads, they should have been able to commission an artist to make ad or at least use the original cover of the novel.

WebNovel website: https://webnovel.com/2
Link to story: https://webnovel.com/book/82129872050063055

This post also serves as warning to all of you artists, beware of art theft! :grinning: Thank you for your time!

  • created

    Jan '19
  • last reply

    Feb '20
  • 16

    replies

  • 3.1k

    views

  • 9

    users

  • 39

    likes

  • 6

    links

It is funny how they've used art with the characters from Code Geass to advertise the novel, which seems to have no relation to this anime. :joy:
Even more absurd thing is that this novel already has cover and they haven't used it... :thinking:
Actually, I think that telling the artist about non-proper using of their art is enough... I would let them decide how to deal with this situation, cause it it their art, after all.

Ugh I really hate art theft..
Seen it on tapas too. People think it’s okay to use official art as if there isn’t an IP behind it, or “really high quality” fanart as if it’s public domain. :sweat:

I currently can't contact the artist, but I'll look for their other contact :sweat_smile:

I'm currently calling out the WebNovel on Instagram. I know it's significant as I lack the mass to and I'll be ignored, but I hope they realize that they can randomly snatch an artist's work for their ads without somebody noticing :triumph:

So, I'm on webnovel and I remember that it was mentioned on their forums somewhere that they aren't doing their ads themselves. They're paying somebody else to do them. Naturally, that doesn't make this better.
If the artist still doesn't react, maybe you could try reaching out to the webnovel people on facebook (or maybe twitter?) instead? They (as in: the people officially working for them) aren't very active in their own forums but I heard it's better on facebook and twitter so someone might react there and look into it.

Thank you for your suggestion :smile:
That's intriguing to know the mechanism behind it.

Unfortunately I don't have Twitter nor Facebook (oops), what I did is only call them out on Instagram (I'm too nervous to DM) :sweat:
I know it's significant as I lack the mass to and I'll be ignored, but I hope they realize that they can randomly snatch an artist's work for their ads without somebody noticing.

I've pinged one of the more active moderators on the forum but can't promise anything.
Maybe somebody else has facebook and could bring it to their attention there too? I don't think webnovel knows about this and would tolerate it if they did so it might just be a matter of getting this to the right person to be dealt with

I just sent them a message with the screenshots and links to the Pixiv page on Facebook!

fwiw, I don't see this ad on their Facebook page, though I haven't scrolled too far... Usually companies will try out different ads on different social medias and they'll try different images too. It's likely they have used other images too........

Btw I've gotten a response at the forum but it doesn't seem promising. The moderator confirmed that the ads are done by a third party and wrote that they can't do much about it. I do hope they'll still forward it to someone from webnovel who can at least get in touch with said third party but right now I'm doutbful much will happen. So I'm afraid the only possibility will be to get a hold of the artist and have them file a complain

That is a disgrace. Art thieves should be held accountable in real life with real jail time.

I hate this kind of legal BS.

They CAN clearly do something about it, what they're saying is legally the don't HAVE to do much about it.

Yeah, I don't understand why they won't do anything either. I mean if I paid someone to do my ads and they clearly just steal an artist's work for that I would immediately demand that person/company to redo the stuff or never work together with them again. Especially if I was a company that works together with authors and has had trouble with plagiarization there too. I mean that's also a trust issue that crops up there if such a company shows it doesn't care about things like copyright, isn't it?

1 year later

closed Feb 4, '20