6444 / 8851
Jul 2021

To be fair, the very first time I listened to it back when it was released it felt weird. The sound was different from the previous albums but then slowly it grew on me. I think what really hit me is the fact that this album seems to have a message and a purpose to it, which I think shines through really well. It feels like an album that needed to be made.

Music wise I also enjoy the slow, ominous mood many of the songs have. I think there is softness in this album that did not exist in the previous ones but it's an angry and melancholy softness, not tenderness. If that makes any sense...

I’ve listened to it again after your comments and I get your point, but I guess this one is just not for me.

Summary

I was expecting for the album to slowly grow on me. MJK had a lot of credit, that’s why I’ve never given up on it and tried to listen to this album in different place, different time, different mood, but at this point it feels that it’s never going to click... some songs are really good individually, but I feel that:
1. some other songs really drag the whole thing down (like ‘so long...’, or the beginning of 'hourglass', I just can’t, it’s too conventional to me)
2. the album seems undecided (or at least i don't get it and I'm not moved by it either), like lost somewhere between moods and ideas, too polished and bright to be raw, too angry to be reflective, it feels like floating in a weird place that never align with me...

Edit: That 'hiding' function thing never work for me... don't know why...

I totally understand and I think sometimes albums require a specific space of mind to really hit. Sometimes I've really wanted to like an album but it wasn't the right time or the right place for it. If Eat the Elephant had been released 10 years ago I'm not sure at all I would've liked it this much. But sometimes some albums just don't hit, and that's unfortunate but it happens.

I agree that the album isn't as raw as the older ones, but that again worked for me personally in this case. I struggle a bit trying to find the right words in English but I think this album doesn't have the despair that was so obvious in their previous work. This album is more about discontent in my opinion, so it makes sense for me that it's less raw and more direct.

I think one of the greatest things about music is that everyone can have their own favourite albums and choose which ones they like and don't, and still be fans of the same band.

I’m feeling so old all of a sudden... :tea: