Yes! This is exactly the kind of thing I'd prefer to see. That way the characters feel more like actual well-rounded people, and not just billboards representing a specific gender/orientation.
ABSOLUTELY! That is something I really don't want people thinking. Like @joannekwan said, background noise can help out a lot, but there's still that thing, when, if ever, is it right to out your OCs?
And I am an ESFP, Pisces, Gryffindor, Rising Gemini, Sun Pisces, Moon Gemini, straight-ish, male, he-him pronoun having person! Hi! Follow me pls. LMAO!
I think it's not so much that people are finding artists from tumblr on purpose but rather, certain art trends that are really popular especially on tumblr find their way here and on other webcomic or art sites.
You can look up Tumblr Nose, there's a Know Your Meme page that comes up and is pretty accurate. I don't really think they're as popular these days. I read once that it was popularized around the time some new Animal Crossing game came out? Dunno how true that is.
But, I mean, art trends come and go. It's totally fine not to like a certain thing, opinions are subjective, but there's always gonna be that annoying fad or cliche lol.
Speaking of pet peeves....here's one of mine. Okay, so this isn't so much character design as just weak artistic skill, BUT OLD PEOPLE WHO JUST LOOK LIKE YOUNG PEOPLE BUT WITH WRINKLES AROUND THE MOUTH FREAK. ME. OUT. There's more to looking old than wrinkles.
HAHAHAHA!!! That used to be me at the beginning of this year before my professor kicked my ass and taught me about gravity and how it affects skin lmao!
i actually have more pet peeves designing characters than looking at other characters lol. but if i had to pick my major pet peeve, it's impractical clothing purely meant for fanservice. it's cool if it's just a few characters, but i see this with almost every single female character in any sort of media and it's so aggravating. same for when every character has the same body type, face, skin color, etc.
as for your number three, i actually think it's neat when people try to mix it up and defy traditional associations like that. i mean, that can be overused too, but i don't necessarily see it as someone getting the colors 'wrong'. i have two characters with a yin-yang color scheme because they're the elements of light and darkness -- but neither are male or female, so you can't associate either one with gender.
I really like the red nose design aspect as well HAHA when it's toned down and doesn't stick out too much from the skin it can actually be pretty cute and, I think, it adds contrast and thus brings attention to the face. Again, it's in moderation...like personally, when the blush is red enough for someone to put a Highlight in it, it rubs me the wrong way.
I feel bad attaching "Tumblr" to it 'cause it's a bit reductive. I've seen it even in japanese hentai and, alas, in some professional comics.
To compensate I'll add that I think pink hair is freaking amazing and I'm ready to fight anyone who thinks otherwise ; )
(too) Big chested girls.
Eyes that big, they don't even allow the character to have a forehead.
Foreigners being blonde with blue eyes. (I understand why, but well…)
Cat/animal mouths on human characters, like this -> :3
I do sometimes like animal ears and other accessoires, but not if they always wear it.
Now that I look over the list again, everything mainly happens in mangas haha
Why so? No matter where you live, there's plenty of blonde blue-eyed people from foreign countries out there. :?
Yes that's true, but I feel like they restrict themselves by designing them like that.
A lot of foreigners have brown or black hair too (many have brown eyes, though I only met two people until now who had green eyes…).
Anyways, it's not like the readers wouldn't believe they'd be, for example, french if they don't have blonde hair.
That's what I meant p:
I guess a pet peeve of mine would be when a character outfit is clearly out of place or occ.
Examples would be Orihime from bleach in the sternritter arc:
Previous arcs:
http://vignette4.wikia.nocookie.net/bleach/images/8/86/Episode_347_Orihime.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/250?cb=20111109040237&path-prefix=en5
http://www.absoluteanime.com/bleach/orihime[4].jpg5
She isn't a sexual character or anything like that. So her choice of clothing here doesn't make sense. It's made worse when Kubo excuses it by saying she wearing it for Ichigo. URGH.
Or in Corpse Party Blood Drive with the addition of new characters. Imo, it's has one of the worse designs.
I start by saying Corpse Party (kind of) followed a "theme" with their character designs. Like most characters either have black/brown hair and a uniform. That's it. With these new characters it feels so deviantart like anime now
What's bugs me the most is Kuon Niwa's design. She supposed to be really skinny but she has huge breast. I feel if you're going to make a character that's a sick and aging rapidly then go all the way and actually make her skinny.
But it's not a huge deal breaker. I just feel it's out of place.
2 months later
Oh and let us not forget the dreaded BOOB WINDOW!
As in a picture with Orihime, which @Maxiachan posted above.
I mean it's pretty uncomfortable type of clothes, especially if you have big breasts.
Oh yay someone revived this thread so I can complain about another peeve of mine I've realized recently:
Plain shirts. Just. plain. fucking. shirts.
Like HOW OFTEN do you HONESTLY see someone walking down the sidewalk with just a SOLID green or yellow t-shirt. With literally no pattern or logo on it. Plane WHITE t-shirts are sort of different, but every time I see just a solid green or yellow or blue shirt that has literally no design on it, I'm just kind of like "please at least put a STRIPE on it or something."
It just makes me feel like everyone is in a TV commercial where any logos or designs could get them sued. Please just put a jacket on them ore a stripe or something on the shirt D:
It's kind of funny, cause unless it's from a franchise I REALLY like, I absolutely HATE designs on my shirts and go out of my way to just find plain shirts with nothing on them. (Even more of a pet peeve for hoodies with zippers at the front if the zippers CUT THROUGH a picture or logo... it just... makes me so angry) Even with my shirts that have pictures on them I mostly only wear them at home. I just... I duno... I just really HATE going out with pictures/logos/patterns or designs on my clothes.
It's actually harder to find coloured shirts with NOTHING on them then you would think, unless they are meant for layering. I remember as a kid I was always angry how it couldn't be how it was like in cartoons, where it was apparently REALLY EASY to find shirts without crap on them, since EVERYONE had them.
So yeah, with that I actually like the plan shirt thing that happens a lot in drawings. It's just... satisfying... I duno lol
I think Vitiligo is probably one part of tumblr's "unique and inspirational" character design. They'll likely be pudgy, neurotic, pink haired, missing a leg, etc.
I feel it works if it fits in to the plot. Like someone is dating someone of the same sex or something natural. Lots of times it's just introduced it follows tropes like: everyone in school hates the gay kid or lol grandma hates trans people.
Well if you got a teen character going through a phase I doubt that needs explanation.
I can see that side of things! But your difficulty in finding plane colored tees just makes it clear...OFF it is to have an entire cast of characters in nothing but plain colored tees (without any layering). At least in a...realistic sense I guess? :'D
I have a lot of plain TANK TOPS that I use for layering, but yeah, I can't think of any time I've actually just...seen a colored t-shirt completely plain for sale in store. Most of the time, you have to order them from sites that have them in stock (to print things on and make them not plain lol).
It's definitely not a matter of me thinking its UGLY to have plain shirts, it's more so along the lines of if I see a whole cast of plain shirts all I can think is "Where did you all find these shirts? Who sold you these?? Did you all collectively decide to order plain colored tees?? You can't find these at fucking Target"