Which style do you prefer?

[Edowado_Fujji]

Hellow I am new on tapastic. I am wondering which style of art is better for my comic. I usually work digitally and traditionally, each way have the goods and bads. I will post the two drawings of the same character in two differentes technics what I did use please say which style you prefer.

Thanks

[Aetherwing]

I definitely like the first one better. The shading/inking is very nice and consistent.

[Edowado_Fujji]

Thank you very much for your comment. I think is a lot more clear, but is a lot more hard to do. I used the same technic in the fist chapter of my webcomic http://tapastic.com/series/Farewell-My-Home but I did spend a lot of hours. Thanks

[Jrej]

I like the first one too.
You definitely need a style you're comfortable with.
It shouldn't take you too long to draw or you gonna burn out before the end.
Good luck with your comic. It looks very promising!

[dracoplato]

That technique looks incredibly nice in your comic.

[Edowado_Fujji]

Thanks for the advice. I am trying to make something what would can "simplify" my work. Because I like so much do a detailed work in ilustration, but for a comic I will need something more simple.

[Edowado_Fujji]

thank you very much :D. I am doing my best.

[jmhenry]

Gotta go with the first one!

[Chiper1811]

First one! It's so much bolder. I like it!

[Edowado_Fujji]

thanks. I will try something like that in next works.

[Edowado_Fujji]

Thank you I appreciate your attention.

[Edowado_Fujji]

Thank you very much for your opinion.

[mappypaint]

They look good to me but the 2nd one somehow looks unfinished to me. So I must say the first one... I really like that traditional feel. ^u^

[Edowado_Fujji]

thanks for help me. The first one was made with real traditional stuffs. (Moleskine sketchbook and mechanical pens)

[mappypaint]

Thats cool! I use tech pens and a fountain pen for my comic. But for coloring I had to go digital since traditional coloring materials are expensive.XD There's something about traditional inking that pleases my eye so i'm looking forward for more pages.

[mg78]

could be very nice the second test BUT with realistic eyes.
a manga style eyes in that style picture imho ruin all...

[Edowado_Fujji]

I am in the same ship ^.^

[Edowado_Fujji]

Could be the problem, thanks for the advice.

[Edowado_Fujji]

Thank you everyone for the advices I posted a new chapter of Farewell My Home.

Farewell My Home- Chapter two: A common life

http://tapastic.com/series/Farewell-My-Home

I used traditional lines as the people said(and I think the same) is better.

Here one of the panels of the chapter:

I hope everyone enjoy.

[Spinester]

I like the first one for the contrast alone. Much more stark and lively.