Which thumbnail do you like best?

[drawnbyyannan]

Just as the title says, which thumbnail composition do you think is best?

(Context: The story is a supernatural romance about a ghost (the girl in glasses) trying to make it to the afterlife. It's not a comedy but it's also not too serious. It's a fun read that will hopefully also punch you in your feelings. Edit to add: the guy is a writer, hence the pencil&notebook in a couple of the thumbnails)

[IndigoShirtProd]

I think #2 has the most interesting composition. My eye is drawn to that one.

[TheGentleArtist]

I say number three.

[noenoh]

according context, 3 is the best
I like 2 as a poster
Im drawn to four but for something else

[MeltingCORE]

I'm gonna also vote for number three!

[DarkChibiShadow]

I think 1 and 4 have the best crop for including the title of the series (if you plan on using this for the cover, at least) but 2 and 3 give off the best vibes for the story and let us know details like, oh, one character is a writer and the other is supporting them. Hope that helps!

[Aleksei]

Number 3!
I can see the book there, unlike the other ones.

[LadyOttoline]

Number 3 is the best!

[migxmeg]

2 seems the most interesting to me - it's got some tension with the writer looking off screen.

[wekanian]

Number three! It looks the nicest to me, then number 4.

[LunarScyphozoa]

2 and 3 look the best

[TadxSarah]

I think number 3 is the best

[FafasMcMelt]

3rd has the most going on. Go for it

[vinoff]

Agree with the majority. Number 3 looks the best.

[Dialusion]

2 and 3 are clear winners in my eyes. They immediately jumped out to me and I could tell it involved writing. 3 is my favorite between em, but it feels too ordinary. 2 is a lot more interesting when I compare the two.

[DanielRKM]

My gut says 3. 2 is really interesting, but 3 is clean and gets your point across really well.

[BarBarKetrab]

Number 3, in my opinion.

[jimena]

Number 2 & 3! I think #2 is very interesting and #3 has a good composition

[jmhenry]

3 feels like the best one!

[lumisullivan]

I feel like I'm the odd one out but I like number 1 the best!