2 / 8
Apr 2020

Hi everyone!

One thing I do a lot (In novels I've since pulled to publish and some that are upcoming) is write stories for public domain characters such as Robin Hood and Sherlock Holmes. Now, right now I'm in the process of rebooting a character that was released into the public domain by his still living creator who I'm a fan of. I won't say who since I want to wait till the story is ready for a reveal. What I'd like to know is, should I share this with the original creator and thank him for the opportunity to use the characters? I'm not going to lie, while it's full of potential (why I'm rescuing the story) it was one of the worst web comics I've ever read. The plot's going to be much more fleshed out and other than appearances and character names it might as well be a new story. If you were the original creator, would you want to know someone re imagined your comic as a novel? And would you want to be credited as the original creator?

  • created

    Apr '20
  • last reply

    Apr '20
  • 7

    replies

  • 963

    views

  • 4

    users

  • 7

    likes

How accessible is the original creator? I'm also planning on making a series for public domain characters, though it's an illustration series as opposed to an actual story, and all of the original creators in my case are dead. So, if you have a rapport with the original creator, or you know you can even contact them, then sure go ahead. But if the creator is a celebrity of some sort, then I don't think it's necessary. Your situation reminds me of people making fan comics of popular stories, like Harry Potter and Steven Universe, and I don't think the people involved go to J.K. Rowling or Rebecca Sugar to tell them even though those characters are still copyrighted.

He retweets a lot of my stuff on twitter. We aren't more than acquaintances but I do commission art from his wife several times a year so I know her a little better. He has a review show on youtube so hes a decently popular internet personality,

So they know you! Since that's the case, then go ahead and tell them, I'm sure they'll be happy.

I would share the news. It might be deeply gratifying to the original creator that something has been remembered and found inspiring. There is really no potential downside because the original creator cannot stop you. It makes little difference if you do it now or when your comic launches.

It isn't the standard here on Tapas, but a few of us do use public domain characters. I've used characters from classic literature in my stories. A couple of guys here have done amazing things with golden age comic book superheroes. I had a thread going a couple of years back about Tapas series eith public domain characters, but almost nobody was doing that at the time.

Out of curiosity, how did the original creator specify that the story or character was being gifted to the public domain? There are a few different ways of doing this. Personally, I release stories with a Creative Common license. CC is not technically the same thing as public domain, but effectively it's the same thing. This way, the terms of exactly what can or cannot be done with them are spelled out and no confusion should result.

let him know sure! may want to leave out the part where his comic is the worst ever though. lol

He outright stated in an official post he was releasing the comic into the public domain.