Since even narrowly dodging an attack still gives you that chill, it means that mere physical contact is dangerous. Blocking attacks or dislocating limbs is out of the question, although if she feels confident, she might deliberately tank some damage to end the fight as quickly as possible.
In any case, the plan is to aim for the neck with a punch or the head with a kick. And just in case, use Searing Smite on the strike to add fire damage. If it survives such a blow, then immediately afterward she would perform a technique to snap its neck.
