Now, I'm a long time Silent Hill fan. It had a huge influence on how I design monsters that are a threat and how I write horror. I also always admired how SH boldly embodied sin in its monsters and how everything about them makes them disturbing to look at. With that said, one of the reasons I especially loved Silent Hill 2 is because it bravely explored themes like rape and resentment even when there is love involved. This is also why the monsters were all especially bone chilling. Each of them was a mix of lust and violence hence the objectification of the female body yet they were still frightening monsters. Even Pyramid Head, he debuted in SH2, had sexual themes. That was the whole point of the game. It all had a purpose.

However, in the first look at the remake, I have to admit I don't like what I am seeing. I feel like many of the key edges have been shaven off and things get lost in the translation. To start, I don't like that Angela is larger. I preferred her being very skinny and looking frail because it added to her character. It made her look more sad and vulnerable. Filling her out a bit makes her look... average. And it may be a nitpick with me, but I liked the old clearly traumatized Angela better. I also don't like that the nurses are more petite because like I said before, the objectification of the female body was a part of what made them disturbing to look at: they had super idealized bodies yet hideous faces and behaviour. Lastly, we need to talk about Maria's outfit... Her original outfit was as iconic as James'. It was also a part of her character in how it made her look alluring and seductive especially with animal print dress. I'm not saying the new outfit isn't pretty. It is, but why did James get to keep his iconic look while Maria had to change hers?

I would also like to add that I am just judging the images I have seen. Not the game itself. I can't judge a game I haven't played, but I see the pictures and I don't like what I'm seeing in some of the iconic characters.

Am I the only one who feels this way?

PS: I'm still going to give the game a chance. Besides, maybe these are just rough drafts.