@poppyqueen01 Here are my personal opinions:
Your first cover comes across as very "busy" to me. There's three or four different fonts all in a very small space , and it's kind of overwhelming. Additionally, the quote in the middle isn't going to be legible at a glance, since tapas covers are real small. That being said, the picture is definitely eye-catching. The blood near the wrist personally makes me real uncomfortable, but that's just me.
The second cover is definitely much easier to read, but the picture is much less memorable, and I like the graffiti/stencil font in the first one more. I don't want to say "None," because they both have good things, so maybe like a happy medium between the two? Both? Again, this is just my personal opinion, and I don't really have the credentials to back it up, but I hope this is helpful! Sorry for the long comment, this is just how I think through things.
Here's my cover. I keep wanting to change it, but I don't have the art chops yet to create good character portraits yet.