1 / 33
Sep 2016

I was thinking about adding my comic to Line WEBTOON just to try and get it out there to more people but I was looking through the Operational Policy's and it seems my comic violates their policy in one specific area (Aside from the occasional curse word)
338

My Webcomic's 2nd chapter revolves around a mass suicide caused by a demon and killing over 96 thousand people, and the demons in my comic also do a lot of the things in that list, murder especially. I'll let you guys be the judge of the Mass Suicide part to see whether it could get taken down or not https://tapastic.com/episode/281380804

Also does anyone else think Line WEBTOONS policies are extremely strict? Like, apart from my question about asking if they're strict as I read through their policies they don't allow you to do hardly anything except slice of life and bloodless action, like something out of Fairy Tail or Naruto where very few to no one actually dies.

  • created

    Sep '16
  • last reply

    Aug '20
  • 32

    replies

  • 21.4k

    views

  • 25

    users

  • 29

    likes

  • 4

    links

This has come up before and no one has heard of them ever enforcing these policies, and how could they, considering pretty much every single comic that's ever existed breaks at least one, and the conditions are themselves self-contradictory.

I mean, you can't criticise religion, but you also can't promote a superstitious or unscientific lifestyle? Huh?

Glorify means "to highly praise something", which is ridiculous.. who would glorify anything on this list?
I think there's nothing to be worried about, these things are just regular disclaimers to keep themselves away from any trouble

explain this part please, how do you think they "don't allow"? do you have a screenshot orrr..

I think you're fine as long as you aren't glorifying things like this. That is, to say suicide is something positive or a bunch of dead people is something to be happy about.

Only someone with a sick mind would make something like that. You have nothing to worry about.

I'm talking about how the policies are structured, you're not allowed to curse, not allowed to show killing, not allowed to show dead people, etc. Which is what some manga's and comics do on a regular basis, take Deadpool and Tokyo Ghoul for example, mass amounts of killing and bodies.
I mean you probably could show blood/some gore in an action series it's just odd how strict those policies look when you look through them, I'm not entirely sure how to explain what I mean.

Seems that they're following the old Comics Code Authority guidelines from way back in the day.
The seems way too strict and restrictive so I'd avoid it

Aah yeah, now i getcha,
So, they wanna play it safe, and i guess Webtoons don't have the NSFW warning option like here, yeah?
I see a lot of comics here with a lot of NSFW content, that's gonna be a big bummer :T
. . .
@TACOBERTO, back in the days, the Code was faced with waves of underground comix, i wonder how things are gonna turn into on the Internet?

that "dont promote a superstitious or unscientific lifestyle" part seems the wonkiest. my favorite comics are superstitious and unscientific! most comics are actually right? like magic and monsters and ghosts are all pretty much in that group

Honestly I think these policies are pretty reasonable. Webtoons is shooting for a mass audience, and all of the things they ban are fairly controversial topics. They try to cater to preteens as well as people in their 30s, so they need to keep the amount of mature content fairly low as to avoid offending or discomforting people.
The only one I think is really odd is the rule against portraying gambling, but I imagine you can chalk that up to cultural differences. I think Korea has some different views of gambling than the west.

I think what they mean by that is that they don't want Chick Tracts or comics that promote things like New Age religion. I'm guessing they can differentiate between a comic portraying mythical phenomena and a comic pushing those myths as true.

What it means is don't make a comic specifically and blatantly promoting some kind of religion or superstition. Don't use your comic as a kind of recruitment tool.

Promote a superstitious or unscientific lifestyle?

Umm... so the Amish and ghost believers are out?

man i was thinking about uploading there but my comic violates the no corpses/execution scenes rule in the first 5 pages lmao, there's a whole chapter in my comic where there's a bounty hunter on board the ship my characters are on. like....you can't have any comics with action or character death is what i'm getting from this. these rules are super confusing like it looks like the only thing you can post and not get banned from here are slice of life and romance :/ ??

Some of these rules seem a bit wonky to me, especially the superstitious/unscientific one. I guess that eliminates most fantasy comics then. xD I still haven't added my comic on Line Webtoon yet, might look in to it in the future though.

The rule is there to keep the proselytizing comics out, because those comics are a thing on Korean sites. (Think door-to-door "have you found Jesus"-ers... in webcomic form!)

Oh wow. These guys are pretty strict. It's nothing compared to webtoons on the Korean webtoon site where there's a webtoon in which a teenager kills his tutor and there's this big twist in the end. Of course, it's r-rated so you need to confirm your age and all but still. This is pretty strict.

I don't have any first-hand experience of LINE Webtoon, but I'd like to point out that there's a difference between having scenes of, for example, suicide in your comic, and glorifying or encouraging it. I'm pretty sure most of you aren't writing comics that tell the readers to go and kill themselves (at least I hope so).

Pushing examples to the extreme, "Maus" shows us the most terrible things the Nazi regime did - but it's not glorifying it, on the contrary.

As for the "include execution scene or corpses, causing a strong aversion" part... I feel like the placement of the comma here miiight be a bit wonky... Either they only want you to not post images of corpses that cause "a strong aversion" or they don't want any corpses at all because they cause a strong aversion. Honestly, I can't tell.

If you're talking about 후레자식, that comic is actually on Webtoons too! So the rules aren't as strict as they sound. I figure they're pretty much just covering their asses in case they need to take action. That, and less-than-stellar translation issues with the rules...

Well, I think I already broke one rule xD "include execution scene or corpses." My comic takes place in the afterlife so death is everywhere...

The one that made me scratch my head was " Glorify, encourage or promote violent acts against women and children."
Sooo...what about men?

I'm not sure how the gore rules work. I've seen a recent webtoon chapter feature a MC whose legs and arms were cut off trying to take down Zeus. There's no red blood, it's just black.