I'll rate your comic/novel cover

[Insanebaker92]

(post withdrawn by author, will be automatically deleted in 24 hours unless flagged)

[The_Chosen_Z]

Tks

Read Poketrix :: Capítulo 17: A CAMPEÃ | Tapas Community

[DimlyJolly]

Here's three:

[Tursastheeternal]

Here's the cover I used when I published the first volume in print.

[NGChloe]

rate away

[Paul_Tromba]

Love the title placement, font, and colors a lot! The framing is a bit weird but I assume that is due to chatlracter heights. The runic details are nice. A bit of wasted space due to the framing but not bad at all.

4/5

[Paul_Tromba]

Volume 1
Good title placement and colors. Feels very similar to Disney's Aladdin. Character framing is nice with little to no wasted space.

5/5

Volume 2
Same as before with the placement and font. The character framing is very good still. Though the color scheme feels like it melds together and makes it hard to focus between the eye and blades gem.

3.5/5

Volume 3
Same with the title placement and font as the last two. The color for the title is a nice contrast with the blues. However, it has a similar issue to the last one with the color melding but is not nearly as difficult to find a singular focal point. All three are really good.

4/5

[TheOnsetOfNight]

1st cover
I drew it in hurry

The 2nd cover

[Paul_Tromba]

Out of all the covers I have seen, rarely do I get to see art as traditional and well done as this! As for each cover,
Main cover
The title, character framing, and lighting. The pure white in the background is a little daunting but otherwise great.
4.5/5
As for each individual cover, here's the speedy version,
5/5
4/5
6/5 (this is so good that I cannot explain how good it is!)
4.5/5
4.9/5
5/5

These are all amazing!

[Paul_Tromba]

Love the character framing here. Looks like they are having fun walking somewhere. The title font is well done and well placed. Not a lot of unused space but some at the time that is somewhat filled by the hearts in the background.

4/5

[MK_Wizard]

Here is mine. What do you think?

[Paul_Tromba]

The title has great placement, color, and font. I love the black and white contrast! The art is very well done and the style is unique.

5/5

[Paul_Tromba]

Peak cinema is all I will say.

4/5

[Ferosyne]

First attempt at making cover art.

[The_Chosen_Z]

[XiuLyn_12]

Thank you for your rating and critiques! Agree on the hearts, tbh! I couldn't decide what other elements to add!

[jwabeasley]

Thank you so much for your astute ratings! You have no idea how much anticipation I felt after you reviewed Zhengo's covers. I'm glad you like them.

[Kyanbu]

The main cover for my comic Alterria.

[ambermdo]

Here's mine

[Paul_Tromba]

I'm glad. I wouldn't know what else to put up there either considering the theme. Music notes perhaps? Good job on it!