6 / 10
Jul 2020

Hey all,

I’m a few pages into my comic, but I’m planning on making mine into a printed graphic novel as I conclude my chapters.

Because of this, my original pages look like this:

But obviously Tapas thinks the best format is the scrolling version. So I’ve been cropping and reorganizing by pages into a longer mobile friendly version.

My question is, because my updates are only single pages cropped into scrolling pages, are they too short? Most comics in this format seem to scroll for a lot longer.

Any suggestions? Or do you think it is fine as is?

Thanks and let me know! Here’s the comic for reference:

  • created

    Jul '20
  • last reply

    Jul '20
  • 9

    replies

  • 822

    views

  • 7

    users

  • 16

    likes

  • 1

    link

It's not the best, that's always subjective, but scroll comics get more visibility by default, especially if you use small font sizes. That doesn't change with page length, unless it's like 3 panels an update (because then more time is spent scrolling down/to the side than reading), which doesn't seem to be a problem here. It even makes a VERY quickly read page into something slightly longer if you wanted it that way!

Interesting! Thanks for the advice. I was curious about how the difference would affect the reader.

Hi!
I have a similar issue. My originals are in comic format and i crop and reorganize them. But in order to avoid having a milliard chapters (one for page) I do a chapter for every 4 pages, making them quite longer :smile:

I don't know if it's the best solution, though... I give to you an example on how i'm managing this :slight_smile:


I think long scroll is a more popular format on Tapas and can suit mobile reading well, but it's not strictly "better" and some comics suit it more than others. I often feel it's a worse format for Action comics than stuff like romance or slice of life, for example, because spreading out panels and adding scrolls between them really slows down the pace of an action sequence. I prefer my panel transitions and action scenes snappy, but I guess this is how people consume their comics nowadays and I just have to do my best to supply that.

Personally I run with print pages spread out a bit and with bigger speech bubbles for my comic, and as of the end of the prologue, I switched to two pages stacked into one update a week rather than two single page updates. I found this approach more flexible for storytelling because I could do longer, more involved scenes and conversations without having pauses of several days in the middle for those reading updates on release rather than bingeing or in a book.

Very cool! Yes I had also considered doing multiple pages at once. I’m just so slow lol. I might give that a shot. Thank you!

I was asking myself exatly the same thing !
Scrolling format blows out all the work you put in composing and arranging you panels to make action more dynamic. So I did scrolling format as I thought it was kinda a rule to have "episodes" of 3-5 pages.
But I see so much comics with one pages updates I don't know anymore. Having p1page-chapters doesn't seem to bother the readers, and the new layout makes it more fluid and easy to hop from one to the next.

Still, I would definitely advocate for the scrolling format for one reason : I tried to read on my mobile once, and it makes all the difference ! Printed pages format were impossible to read, where scrolling made it really easy and action didn't seem slow or anything.It was really graphic and you surprise yourself scrolling faster.

I wish that this website would just have a "page format" section or genre tag so then this...wouldn't be such an issue anymore with phone readers reading comics they were never intended to read. (but that's another discussion)

I remember reading this page of yours in scroll cuz I follow your comic--and it was good in scroll, don't get me wrong, but seeing in page--it does feel a lot more complete as a page than it did as scroll. The timing of that little frame really does feel more quick and the last frame does feel longer in comparison, giving a sense of resolution to the action scenes. But, from a business point of view, I would keep it phone format the way you're already doing. Maybe if some images slightly stacked to show they're quick cuts from one panel to another? To give more of that time compression feeling? Maybe? I'm just throwing out ideas because I'm new to converting page to scroll as well.

No, these are great ideas. And you’re totally right that the scrolling format changes the timing of the sequences. Definitely something to think about.

Thank you!

it depends. i sort of prefer single pages, but dont have anything against have a long chain. if it's too long though i can get tired easily. with comics that have been running for years, I like to read the first few dozen pages in 2-3 sittings because it does take some time to get to the good parts of a story and i usually can't pay attention long enough to get there all at once. this is why i like single page updates. no pressure to keep reading. with long, scrolling pages sometimes i get to the middle of the update and there's still like 2 minutes of reading left but im already tired.