Lets try this again: Would you read a comic that looks like this? (+Promo comics with unique style)

[KidJake]

Or find a different creative outlet altogether. Comics is a tough racket for people that apparently need constant approval.

[Rodimus13]

I believe the point was they had mentally prepared for "no" in the other thread but not for a multi paragraph deconstruction of their work when all they had asked for was a yes or no.

Anyway, I would say yes it would get me to check it out at least.

[Rhonder]

Possibly. Story content as well as characterization matters more to me than the aesthetics. The premise from the description seems interesting enough, group of friends/comrades trying to escape a pyramid? Neat~ A strong hook in the first episode or two could probably reel me in.

[ar-ninetysix]

If you ask why anyone wouldn't wanna read a comic like this, chances are they're gonna give you a critical reason to explain why because without that context, it might just seem like a rude answer with no explanation.. The title of the thread kinda opens it up to criticism whether you want it or not tbh not that it's deserved, but it's just inevitable. Not only that, but we don't know exactly where you personally draw the line between actual criticism and plain observations we'd wanna comment on. You don't have to explain, and it's fine, you shouldn't have to. But it is a little harder to approach and give a more thoughtful answer without unintentionally offending you, from the looks of it.

My personal answer btw lol .. it's a no from me right now. I can sorta explain why, but it involves what could be considered criticism. If you're open to hearing it, lemme know, I'll try to keep it super short lol

[UrMom]

Pff I'll leave out the comic promos this time.

Based off the visuals, yeah I probably would give it a go. Mixed media of that nature has always fascinated me, the only other webcomic I know of that does something similar is Weaker Sides (one I linked in the previous forum), it uses a mix of digital, traditional and photography to give a really unique look. It's honestly something I feel should be experimented with more, and has a lot of potential to aid in telling a really compelling story.

As for the premise, it sounds really interesting. It kind of has a 1997 Cube vibe, but with a comic, and I can see how the visual style could be incorporated into part of the story. Other than that I can't really give an opinion since I've learned over the years that it's not about the story you tell, but how you tell it that matters most. You could have the shittiest story on paper, but if it's presented well people will eat it up.
That being said, I would totally check it out! I love having new comics to read!

Anyways, take care of yourself, stranger! Public forums can be a stressful place, especially if you don't have experience with them, or have neurotypical disorder.
If you would like (and you have a Discord account), there is a server that is super positive where you can discuss your comic premise without unsolicited critique. The server is somewhat private being open to only lgbt+ folks, it is run by Support Webcomics, both the owners have webcomics here on Tapas (Beanie and Catuallie) and you can DM one of them to give you an invite.
That is if you want to, of course! Sometimes it's nice to have a place to just talk about your work.

[Sky-Chau]

im prepared for no, not a 7 paragraph bad faith crit. (seriously this would not fly in a fine arts context)

[ben]

Oh, I was reading it differently! That is fair!

[IndigoShirtProd]

I'm not looking to get into an argument, but there's something I want you to understand. I can't help but be passive aggressive when your emotional outburst in the previous thread and some of you comments since have left a bad taste in my mouth. I always try to be considerate of other people when I post in this forum but you just rubbed me the wrong way. I read the WebMD article and I apologize if I caused unneeded distress. Understand that, for the most part, criticism given on this forum is always from a good place and I can say the same for darthmongoose. I, like many other people here, want you to succeed in your artistic endeavors. Being an artist online is going to come with a lot of people not being as considerate as the people in this forum. Even if you have RSD, you shouldn't be surprised when unsolicited advice comes raining down. I'm not saying you have to be alright with it or accept it, just do more to prepare yourself for it. Because reactions like this:

Would you read a comic that looks like this? (+feel free to promote comics with interesting style)

So for fucks sake, don't write crits for people who didn't ask for one, it's not that hard to mind your own business.

won't go over well even though you have a good reason for it. Again sorry but I still think this whole thing could've been sidestepped with a poll.

[azzy-m]

I'd probably click on it if showed up while I'm looking through fresh based on the art, and I'll read a few episodes to see if I'm interested. I don't usually drop comics, so I'll probably read it.

[gempompadour]

Then why not do a simple poll? I don't get why someone asks a forum full of artists if they like a specific style and then expects only a yes or no answers. Art is subjective yes, and you either like or dislike something, but wouldn't they like to know why people love or hate their art? How are they ever going to improve their craft if it can't be critiqued?

[DualDragons]

I think they are quite new to the forums and therefore do not know how to make a poll yet

[gempompadour]

Oh right, I forgot that not everyone lurks here for months before commenting

[SleepingPoppy]

I have no problem with non-anime styles, but in thus case it's just not my aesthetic. I approve of trying new things, though, and appreciate the mixed media approach! I also think your example is much better in this thread than the last one for communicating the hypothetical style.

I will add that I agree with you about not giving unsolicited critiques, however I think it's a very reasonable misunderstanding for someone to give you feedback on their thoughts about your style in a thread asking for feedback about your style. It wasn't a bad faith crit, it was just one that caught you off guard do to miscommunication/understanding.

I hope that everyone will let it go as a misunderstanding. It's hard to shake off a bad interaction, and everyone continuing to push it won't help you acclimate to our forums.

[faeriesandents]

literally what SleepingPoppy just asked to stop.

[Prometheus]

I would read it. It depends a lot on the story, but I like the look of it.

[JRHoch]

********************** No, I wouldn't.

[buttersphere]

I would give it a try sure. The mixed media does fascinate me so I would read the first couple pages to see if it would hook me in.

I have more to say in regards to what happened in the previous thread but I'll respect your wishes and leave it at this.

Thank you for sharing!

[nostalgicroxas]

No. It looks too much like the artwork currently on Disney and Cartoon Network (ie Gravity Falls). Not my preference.

[VibrantFox]

I'd definitely read it, the premise seems interesting and I've been hoping to stumble upon more interesting abstract styles like this. It may not please every persons palette but I'm very curious

[gh0stcr33p]

some people are just being blatantly rude here. what the op said was clear and in no way aggressive. you don't need to be passive-aggressive or hostile just because you don't understand where they're coming from. (I'm sorry if I'm coming off as irritated, I just think a lot of the responses are uncalled for, and I can empathize with the op with being autistic and have quite a few self esteem issues personally).

for myself, I would be open to reading a comic in this style. it's nothing jarring and I normally don't only follow stories that use any particular styles. (but yeah, personally the manga style is an exception with me as it isn't in my interest when reading webcomics).