1 / 12
Jan 2019

I don't really know how to ask this in a manner of which that isn't going to sound weird, but I really want to know this now instead of later.
In a completely black and white, two toned, no grays art-style, how would you go about showing skintones? Like, an african american skintone, or latino or such? Would you just leave it white, or cross-thatch, or color it black with white highlights? Bear in mind I don't know how to do big boy fancy shading for a weekly comic without murdering myself.
I don't know, and I haven't gotten a clear cut answer, and I'd like to know this now instead of later. Sorry if this sounded weird at all.

  • created

    Jan '19
  • last reply

    Jan '19
  • 11

    replies

  • 1.3k

    views

  • 12

    users

  • 25

    likes

I would use stippling (small black dots to give the illusion of grey scale) or leave it white if their latino/white/asian and black, blacks lines for africans =P

good luck dude

edit: found and example

look for woodcutting art all is made by burning wood so its all black and white =D

Comictones are monotone (just black or white dots) so they would typically be used.

If those aren't available then... I suppose it would be up to the artist in that case. I think it depends on the style. I believe I have seen before where simple lines were used as a sort of shading. I don't have any examples to show atm...

Would depend on the art style, but I would just leave the skin without anything to indicate tone. In some people their ethnicity will be evident any way, and in some not, but unless you have a natural way to indicate it, less can be more.

But yeah, I agree with the others that you can use other art methods (hatching, lines, dots) if you're able to make that look appealing. But it could be a great challenge to work on one's ability to draw different facial features instead of focusing on tone as an indicator.

I would suggest using screentones. If you're using Clip Studio Paint it has screentones built in or for download, but for another art program you'll be able to find them online I think.

This was the case with my own comic, too, since I do backgrounds in monochrome purple and all the characters are done in black/white. I started using greyscale for some characters to indicate their skin tones and it looks fine- maybe you could consider adding some grey, see how it looks :slight_smile:

Screentones are really great and you can find screentones patterns and even brushes (I think I saw some on deviantart)!

Looking at black and white photos of those ethnicities would prob help