@globuline - I think you read my mind. I wanted to write a pretty extensive post about this topic, perhaps on Medium.com. Let me give you a short version here.
I want to give my two cents and I hope anyone who reads this don't take my words the wrong way. Some might criticize me as being biased because I do work at Tapastic, which is a self-publishing platform somewhat similar to your owned-and-operated publishing websites. However, as an insider who talks to experts in the fields of both comics + technology, I think I have a good understanding of the challenges and opportunities of our industry.
Game Theory
Have you watched A Beautiful Mind? The movie popularized the game theory. Basically, the whole web comic industry is worse off because a majority of comic creators are individually trying to drive traffic to his or her own website. To use the example from the movie, every wants the dream girl, but if everyone gives up the dream girl for less popular, everyone wins. Similarly, most comic creators today want to be the next theOatmeal.com, xkcd.com, and Cyanide & Happiness, so everyone loses.
Competitive Advantage & Specialization
Basically, it's very difficult for someone to create comics + build a website + run a shop + do everything else. In order to maximize production/output/quality, it's better if you do more of the things that you're good at (making comics) and do less of the things that you're not as good at (making and maintaining websites). A decade ago, one person may have been able to get a website up and running. Today, it's much different. There are specialists for web, iOS, Android, UX design, etc. Technology is moving fast.
Personalization
I highly respect and understand creative people and their desire to personalize their website. But, is that really what readers want or is it what you as a creator want? From our users studies and feedback, there are differences with what readers and and what creators want. There's a reason we continue to push Mobile/Vertical Format. Oh, and everyone wants a better and faster Andriod and iOS app.
Platform Power
I believe that the comics industry in the digital age started off on the wrong foot. What benefits can platforms like Tapastic bring?
- Discovery - I think most community members are already realizing this.
- Advertising (+ other monetization) - We are able to go to advertisers and demand higher rates. Can you? Your 100,000 views are worth more on Tapastic. As we get bigger, we can command even higher rates. As technology develops, better rates.
- Deals - Juju's Diary was picked up and now publishing in South Korea. Golf Star was a collaboration with a gaming company. We want to do more but currently don't have the time and resources. However, more cool things will come. Movie deal? We could see something like that happening sometime in the future.
These are just a few examples. Are we dreaming? No. Our investor Daumkakao is already doing it in Korea including movies and Korean dramas. We believe that we can do something similar globally.