I guess it's a matter of repetition. It's just like with some of these threads that aren't jokes but keep asking the same thing over and over:
The most recent being "Post your comic that's under 100 subs" and "Post your update for August 2019"
I literally saw 2-3 threads with this exact same title, and I was at the point where I'm going "do people just not read before making a thread? Do they just ignore the "Hey -- this thread is similar to XYZ" that pops up when you make a thread?"
And quite frankly, if it gets so long that there's over 1000 replies with little to no interaction, I would personally feel like it just wasn't a good topic in the first place? That's just my idea, though.