37 / 47
Aug 2017

Got my PM, will start commenting today. Making sure that we're supposed to leave comments on at least 5 pages, right?

I'm a little unsure, because we're meant to comment on 5 pages but I've been assigned a comic that only has 3...
Of course, I've left comments but I can't exactly leave 5 comments on 3 pages.

That is fine, you can leave comments as much as the pages allow you to ^^

Happy commenting, everyone! If this goes well, we'll open round two next month!

I would love some feedback on my comic :slight_smile:

It's kind of a long journey to this point, and I am afraid I will mess it all up.

Submissions are cosed, try again next month! :grin:

@ everyone else : Lemme know if you haven't received your comments in five days!

An idea for next round: Could we specify whether we want criticism or comments, and/ or both?

I second this notion!

I agree! I'll enforce them next time.

One more day to comment!
Let me know if you haven't got your comment yet by tomorrow!

Got my comments! I got @Michelle and she is super amazing! I'll try to follow her footsteps in leaving comments in other's works!

So glad you liked the comments! :3 I enjoyed this exchange and getting a chance to see a new comic.

This seemed like a interesting experiment. I hope it returns so I can contribute. I could not join because I´m on vacation. Oh well!

Hello, a few assigned commenters haven't really commented on their assigned comic, this is almost the seventh day for me.

Since my first PM went unanswered, I am calling you out @mbdelgados and @SakebiSensei to fullfil your part on the trade for THREE MORE DAYS

@Marton : I think I will host again next month! :smiley:

I apologise to have not done my part sooner, I was kinda busy in the last days (and I expired all my cellphone internet credit).
I hope I can incur in you forgiveness, my lady.

Hi!
As I already wrote, I wasn't home for a week now, and I just arrived yesterday. I will do my part now!

I'm very sorry for being late! ;A;

Thanks everyone for fulfilling your part! Let's do it again next time!

2 months later

Part two now open!

2 months later

This thread was open to comic creators, not novelists. That's reasonable given how it takes longer to read a novel chapter than to read a typical comic page. Novelists exchanging comments with each other, however, is a fair and feasible thing. I tend to leave feedback when I some prose anyway, so it would not be much more effort for me to commit to a requested comment.

Is any other novel writer (or poet for that matter) wanting to give this a try?

Make a thread for it and i'll jump on ship sometime tomorrow (busy with a chapter today).

@Zaboem Instead of comments why don't we do what professional writers do for others? Write a blurb for the story we read, I think that would be something more interesting than just comments for us novelists.

I am not sure if a blurb would be as useful for everyone since that is not a part of the Tapas system. Eh, you are probably right. Maybe the requester could specify if one wants a blurb, a critique, or just any old comment.

A dedicated thread is an excellent suggestion.