23 / 27
Apr 2020

We didn't have the editorial resources to update this section as frequently and as diligently as we'd like to. Identifying and reading through every new novel published on our service was a taller order than we were prepared to deal with. With the current lack of proper infrastructure and limited bandwidth, we needed to put a temporary pause on this section this morning and collectively find a more scalable solution. We hope to address this later this year.

We are fully committed to improving the overall novel writing experience on Tapas and have begun new partnerships to help with this process.

We've tried previous iterations of the homepage with the FRESH section being surfaced but decided against having that due to the prevalence of spam/bot, sketch, or non-comics related series being created. We wanted to make sure that the front page maintains a comics and novels first approach to avoid any brand confusion. We are experimenting with a fresh section on the mobile apps on the community pages which are slightly curated.

Michael, I haven't been hit by the spam bots, but by their combat measures. When is the I'm not a robot thing going to come off my wall? It's been there since I had the problems with getting the right email address associated with my account.

Sorry about that. I'm having a little bit of difficulty understanding the issue - did the issue arise after you changed the e-mail associated with your account? Or did the issue occur prior to that?

Can you email me at michaelson@tapasmedia.co with a link to your profile including information of a) the previously associated email address and a screenshot of the bug that you're experiencing. Thanks!

As much as I understand these reasons, and feel grateful for you telling us...
Why do it after having changed your selection?
I was one of the lucky picks, and I felt so happy and joyous and got a lot of views, only to see on the next day that the section had disappeared... I mean, I know it is a lot of work, and I'm not questionning your choice at all, but I do have a bit of an issue understanding the timing of it...

Also, will the noteworthy comics be taken down as well?

As stated previously, we temporarily took it down to audit the collection. The collection is still visible on the web and app.

@michaelson I hope this isn't too brazen, but while we're on the topic of novels I've been wondering about something. Is it perhaps possible to split the trending section in 'trending comics' and 'trending novels'? I feel that with how it's currently set up, comics naturally push trending novels to the background. More often than not 9/10 works in trending are comics, simply because they generate more readers quicker.
I think separating them might give novels a fairer chance to be seen, and makes it so that people don't stumble on a novel when they want a comic, or vice versa.

I understand that you're all very busy, but this may be a nice improvement to add when more time is available :slight_smile:

Ugh, but having the FRESH section buried puts pretty much everyone else who isn't on the front page at a disadvantage. Come to think of it, how does the trending section work, anyway? I've seen people with a little less than a hundred subscribers get on there, and it makes no sense. The only way to get noticed on this website is if you somehow make it onto the front page. Otherwise, the FRESH section is the only thing you have...

A series gets on the trending page when it sees a lot of activity (comments, likes, views, etc.) at any given time interval (last I checked it was every 30 min) compared to every other series on the site. What constitutes 'a lot' is calculated by the ratio of activity to how many subscribers the series has.

I think that's a great suggestion - and something that we've been thinking of. One of the restraints is doubling the overall number of items on the front page, and we would want to try and tackle this will a clean, aesthetically pleasing solution that isn't going to add too much business to the overall front page experience. So... basically, we want to add more stuff while reducing the amount of stuff which is a conundrum.

I believe that there are (currently in the works) more effective solutions and opportunities to surfacing more novels on the app side then there are on the web. But I agree that separating out a trending or popular section specifically for novels makes a lot of sense especially because as is it might be a bit confusing since both have square thumbnails and isn't easily distinguishable from one another at face value.

I don't think there's a really good solution to this problem, and it is something that almost all large platforms struggle with.

Try to think about it this way, the Fresh section is the most rapidly updated section on the site and app. If you look at the last visible page (5) right now, the last series to update was a little less than 5 hours ago, meaning that the window for exposure in the Fresh section is roughly 5 or 6 hours. Depending on the day, there could be more than 1,000 updates, reducing the window to 3 hours or less. While I understand that the Fresh section is an avenue where creators can be discovered, it's not entirely effective due to the those windows of exposure.

We purposefully created algorithms for trending section to reward engaging series (novels or comics) so if creators are actively promoting their work, or engaging with their readers, they'll have a much higher chance of being on the front page for an extended period of time which benefits them more.

If we were to surface Fresh beyond what is already there, and with the style of the trending, popular, or new and noteworthy section, the window for exposure would be minutes.

Hope that makes sense!

Absolutely, and without giving away the secret formula, we try to weigh it to be as proportional as possible to give newer creators a shot.


Okay this thread is kind of getting derailed from the original discussion and purpose, so I'll be only responding to questions pertaining to the spam bots moving forward. I'll try to have more open Q&As moving forward though and hope that this has been helpful for those interested!

Update to the spam bots: We have banned several thousand spam accounts. However, there are some spam accounts that were subscribed to series. If you notice a significant drop, it may be due to this. It looks like the spam bots were automated to subscribe to series to be less suspicious.

If I ever find spambot posts on my wall, I'm going to scambait them. The entire point of using bots is time-efficiency. Wasting the of scammers might discourage the targeting of this sight again, and it should feel satisfying. If the results are even slightly entertaining, I might post them as a new Tapas series. As of right now, my wall is not worthy of spamming.

Hey, does anyone else have this problem? I can’t watch ads anymore since every time it directs me to this black page:

And if I click on the black area it directs me to another black page :

Pressing “done” only brings me back to the previous page. The only way I can get out of this loop is by shutting down the app. Might be a problem unique to my phone? Just checking.

EDIT: never mind! For anyone who has this problem, you just need to close and reopen the app each time you watch an ad

10 months later
8 months later

Sorry for the comment on an old post but I cant seem to find a more recent forum thread.

What should we do if we get a spam comment from an obvious bot on our comic series?

I cant find a way to block or delete the spam comment that links to an outside, and possibly nefarious website. What should we do?

closed Apr 14, '20

unlisted Apr 14, '20

listed Apr 14, '20