I'm somewhat creatively burnt out towards the end of this year, so all the energy I've got for artsy gifts will be going to drawing the line-up of my partner's characters, from stories and posts on a roleplay forum he frequents. It's by no means a surprise- I know he's very excited about it x') (which makes me happy too, if a little performance anxious)
Other than that, I've been trying to find small, reusable environmentally conscious things to give people. If I can't make them, I aim for things by other artists/crafters. Novelty teas in decorative tin boxes you can keep. Colourful sculpted soaps. Basically small, inexpensive, but chosen with a friend's particular quirks in mind.
Normally I really don't like shopping for things. But I love giving gifts, so it balances out xD