Which comic platform is safest to use?

[RedLenai]

I believe there are platforms such as INKR Comics (I have a friend whose content couldn't be accepted on webtoon, tapas or any of the well known platforms that are pretty popular, so he had a hard time until he find this one)

If I recall correctly, Lezhin and Webcomics App are a bit less strict than Tapas, and definetly have a more tolerant userbase, so you won't deal with SJW readers most of the time or risk yourself to have your content reported by them at the point Webtoon automatically removes it.

Another site that either require minimal censorship o can be just... nude with the tiniest mosaic in genitalia is Pixiv, and the english userbase is increasing so it's more likely to find readers

You can also publish your work on FurryAffinity (Not only for furry, and comics can be honest, if tagged properly like the rest of the artwork but the layout of the platform is not adapted for comics, at least from what I remember)

[TroyVSTheWorld]

I recently started hosting on Comicfury and it's hands down the least censored. All the gore and banging your heart desires! It's more indie driven, so if you're trying to appease the overlords at Tapas or Webtoon there's certainly not as much money in it's but there's plenty of exposure. I just think it fits my comic's vibes more than these corporate webcomic apps.

[Enthriex]

Ohh the not having issues was on webtoon? Maybe it's a russian roulette then, as in, if you're unlucky they censor you (?)

[BlairFujin]

Comicfury, flowfo, epico are censorship free, globalcomix is fine with what used to be acceptable on tapas back when I joined

[UrMom]

Comicfury and The Duck Webcomics. They're both veteran sites that have been around since the early 2000's, and allow anything outside of hate speech. They both have their own little perks too. Comicfury is the closest you'll get to a free stand alone site since you can customize your comic landing page and all that, the community is also really nice and active for it's size. The owner of CF is also a really nice guy just running the site in his spare time, so no big corporations involved. The Duck, while not being customizable and a little more tacky looking, holds annual reward events, weekly comic spotlights, weekly Twitter Q&A's and regularly posts news updates that encourage engagement.

Both sites have forums as well, which is nice.

[Enthriex]

Ohh I see, the exposure seems appealing BD and yeah I'm interested to have like another backup site since tapas and specially webtoons feel like time bombs XD One can think their content is okay until the platform just says otherwise :s

[NickRowler]

I get far less readers on Webtoons, so maybe no prudes have read my stuff yet. But like I said, my stuff isn't sexy.

[Enthriex]

Yeaaah the problem with webtoons is that it doesn't have to be sexy xD Just googling you can find people complaining about webtoon deleting things like a character changing clothes (without being sexy) or even girls with cleavage which doesn't have to be sexy, I remember one person complaining the girl barely had any and it got deleted anyways.

Hmm... I wonder if it's really the page or people just reporting for the sake of it :0

[Enthriex]

Niceee, thanks for the recs, I think Comicfury sounds like a good backup site just in case. Also, it's nice you pointing out the friendly community so it does sound cool ^^

[NickRowler]

I heard some of the user on Webtoons can be a bit intense if you piss off the wrong crowd. I have heard that people will show up to complain about kid/teenage characters using cuss words and petty stuff like that. There is issues with dog-piling there and review bombing comics out of spite.

[UrMom]

No problem, I like CF, have been on there for YEARS and want more people to be on it. I myself was going to use it as my main site, in case my comic got kicked off Tapas and Webtoons, before I got picked up by a collective.

[BoomerZ]

I have literally two characters discussing something and one is in the shower. This is published on webtoons with zero problems. I had one character rip the arms off of someone in full view of the reader, zero problems on webtoons. Once again pg-13 is the goal to shoot for on an all ages platform. It's how you present it. If you think it would get an R rating in a movie, be prepared to censer. You get a warning that my comic deals with mature content as you open it, but I put that in the description so it should come as no surprise to anyone reading it.

[Enthriex]

Hmmm... With the replies here I actually am thinking the ones truly making webtoon delete their pages are the users reporting the pages, since there's people that have complained over pg-13 things getting deleted by webtoon.

So if it's the users, then it's not a matter of how you present but who read the page and got offended by it for some reason :0

It'd be cool if it was only a matter of how you present it though :'0

Personally, I only got one page down but that was on webtoon (spanish version) not on the english one so I really do wonder what the difference was hmm

[darthmongoose]

It's worth remembering that it's a lot easier for sites like Comicfury and The Duck to be way more lenient on this stuff because they don't have apps and so don't need to worry about Apple's puritanical rules like Tapas and Webtoon do, but that this also means they have far reduced audience reach and that monetisation is entirely up to the creator.

If you're confident that your edgy, adult or raunchy work can build an audience and make money on Patreon and stuff without needing the exposure of being on an app, or your audience falls largely outside the "mostly women around age 20" demographics of Tapas, then making a site or going on Comicfury and The Duck may well be the best way to make your way in comics. Other people may feel that toning things down to a more PG-13 sort of level to fit better on apps and using Tapas and Webtoons inbuilt systems for getting discovered and monetisation are a better bet. Some people also find that having a heavily censored version on apps to point people to the uncensored one on a site or Patreon works well for them.

Ultimately, they're all totally viable options, and you need to do what's best for you and your comic.

[CommissarTarkin]

Comicfury, I guess. The forum community there is really nice as well. Not that the Tapas forums aren't nice or anything, it's just an observation.

[TroyVSTheWorld]

Webtoon is by far the most toxic of all platforms. I suspect it's because of spiteful creators (not readers) who need to bomb others' scores to make themselves look better, since a lot of it stemmed from creators sharing links on creator communities. Also, a complete lack of community of Webtoon makes it feels distant from everything else. Corporate to the max. Ugh, why is my comic even still on Webtoon now that I think about it?

[smokesalty]

I'd say ComicFury cos sometimes I go to update and see the the front page.... (some people are down bad is all I'll say) BUT HEY FREEDOM

But fr- you just gotta mark how much gore/nudity/sexual content is in your comic and it has different levels for each warning. I wish other sites allowed you to do this because webtoon's 'mature' warning barely means anything at this point

[Enthriex]

Yess that's a really insightful comment, thankss Hope this thread can help others decide on this stuff ^-^

I made an account on comicfury since the 'nice community' sounded appealing! Mine is a fancomic so I really look forward to comments more than anything (Since I can't/won't monetize). People have been welcoming me so for the time being it feels good I also like the fact that if anything may happen, I at least have the backup over there

[Enthriex]

Yeaaah, looking around comicfury, it does seem like a nice community ^^

And yes, it's nice this site isn't controlled by apple's guidelines and that is has the option of marking the content like that!

[system]

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.