9 / 22
Sep 2015

Thank you for your reply ^.^
I've tried to mix them but when I use the style A brush for sketchier lineart (like style B) it just looks too messy and unfinished ono!!

Style B is more pleasing to the eye, but that might change if the background on style A wasn't white. Style B's line width is also smaller, making it look more clean.

Honestly, I think I prefer A. It's got heavier lines than B, but it also looks neater - which is partly due to the colouring. The way you've shaded the colours in version B looks... well, it looks messy. And not in the careless sketchiness kind of way - the sleeves and hair in panel one look as if you don't really care about what you're drawing. :T Which obviously can't be true.

You're welcome
Maybe play with it a little?
If I were to settle on just one, I'd say A, and then leave Style B for intense moments?

yeah i vote style A! cuz i like clean art and stuff. but everyones got their own style likes so either would probs be good

I like the more polished style A. Style B is nice, I like sketchy art, but something about it doesn't quite work for me, perhaps it would look better in black and white or something, I don't know, can't put my finger on it.
You could still use both styles and pick the one more suited to a particular work, or if you have an ongoing series, perhaps you can use style A for the regular art and B for flashbacks or other special panels.

Style A I think is def better! Heavy lines separate your main subject from the background and it is easier to see hands and objects and separate hair line from body lines. May I recommend one bit of advice?
Play around with both thickness and thinness of lines from both style A and B. Lines around character Elena for example can be thicker to show she is in the forefront of Felix. (I'm grabbing the names off the speech bubbles presented I hope it's correct haha!)
Anything in front of something else should have the thickest lines to just give a small feeling of depth. Just a nice trick.

Style B is my preference. It's energetic and interesting. It lets you get away with more.

Style A feels a bit too much like MS Paint in my opinion. It's far too rigid and obvious.

I like Style A more Style B looks a little messy. However, Style B looks more authentic while Style look more templated. Maybe you can take the best elements from each and combine them.

I'd say style A but I also think it depends on the drawing style but honestly I like A more.

Style B is what pleases my eye the most when it comes to reading, though style A is adorable looking at. I don't know, maybe try mixing them both-- Like style A with style B's thin lines? I think both are going to look amazing no matter what you choose!

Sorry for the late reply ono!! There seems to be a daily post limit(?) and then uni got in the way also.

It seems to be split 50/50 so I think I'll vary between styles depending on what suits each comic best and work on neatening my lines for style B and giving more line depth in style A.

Thank you all for your help and advice!!