Would I start reading your comic/novel based on your cover

[Schwarze_Neko]

I just updated my cover! The last one was similar to this but the proportions were off a bit lmao

Nevermore | Tapas

[AwesomeSoFar]

well, I've read episode 0. I'm honestly not sure what's going on but it seems pretty interesting!
I've read further now, and I like the premise. failed cyborg experiments that live in a futuristic scrapyard isn't something you hear of every day! I subbed!

[InfinityBeerwizard]

will I click on it?
- It looks intruiging so I might!!
what's my opinion
- I think it's cute! I like the simplistic art style and colours
what can be better
- The background's a little lacking but other than that I think it's awright

Heres mine lol

https://tapas.io/series/Stalemate

[lynestjules]

Will I click on it?

No, the artwork bothers me too much. And it doesn't look like my cup of tea.

What's my opinion

Not a fan of the red font. Possibly a children's short cartoon.

What can be better

The background is not the same style. It looks rushed. Get rid of that red font style/colour on the bottom. Go simpler with the style, use white and make it smaller. It's almost as big as the title.

100% honest opinion: I already did.

I do a cover for each chapter, because they get printed into comic books.

Megami Shiizun | Tapas

[Flauschwurm]

Okay now i‘m majorly confused because… there is no cat on the cover

[liaroger]

Will I click on it
Maybe. It's giving me teenage witches vibes I love witches.

What's my opinion
I love how much variety there is in your cover, they all have their own unique mood, colour scheme and lighting and I like that. My favourite ones are probably the second and third one, you really nailed the composition and lighting there. But every cover looks interesting and unique and I can tell you put a lot of thought into every one of them.

What can be better
You're doing really well already imo ... the composition in the fourth cover with the glowing hand is throwing me off a little, it just looks a bit unbalanced ... I'm not entirely sure how to change it, but I'd suggest either adding more blue light to the rest of the scene or increasing the intensity of the red glow in the background. Or maybe it would help to change the girl's pose so her entire arm is visible. Hrer pose makes sense anatomy wise but in terms of composition it looks a little cramped, her arm is barely visible because it's hidden behind her body and it's very foreshortened so it's not immediately obvious that it's her arm, there's just her face and body and then a hand. Or maybe keep that in mind for future covers of that sort.
And then the burn on the left on the last cover looks a little strane but maybe that's just me.
Besides that I don't have much to critique, I love your colouring and composition overall and the covers tell a story already so that's great.

100% honest opinion
I feel like I was already honest.

This is my cover ^^ I'm planning on editing it soon so I might as well get some feedback on it first.

Prelude | Tapas

[jeffanime1]

Well what o you think?

Manga Academy | Tapas

[PBArt]

You can check out mine too

https://tapas.io/series/The-Girl-of-Prophecy

[malikhill247]

Sure, I just made a new cover and I would like some feedback to know how people feel about it.

Celestials V Hunters

[Saint01]

Will I click on it: Id say its 50/50

What my opinion: Looks like it would be geared more towards younger audiences. I also get a weird video game vibe from it.

What can be better: Going off of the second one, not sure. Then again I'm not the best with critiques sooo

Technocyte: Beyond Human | Tapas

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Yes, could you provide a link to it?

What's my opinion
Characters are great and overall composition.

What can be better
English tittle is barely readable.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.
I wrote better description for the comic so it's easier to understand what it is about.

Good luck on your comic/novel journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Probably not

What's my opinion
Pose of the character is great. I also like what you did with the title.

What can be better
Background is very plain. It's not clear where he is exactly.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your comic journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Most likely no, but there is a chance I would give it a try

What's my opinion
Overall composition is good and I like what you did with the tittle.

What can be better
You need to practice anatomy a bit more. You have this simplistic art stile for a comic witch is great especially if is your fist. Also the character design is great. Also characters on the cover need some room to breathe, as of now some parts of theirs body are cut by the corners.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your comic journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
No it doesn't look like something I would like

What's my opinion
It's really great cover for a book, nothing more to say really it looks amazing.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your novel journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Yes, it seems interesting.

What's my opinion
Really like character design. The idea behind the magician cop sound intriguing.

What can be better
Ears on the male char are a bit to low, also I'm not sure that leg position is stable.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Yeah..... I didn't expect such a huge response to be honest xD

Good luck on your comic journey

[katewindloft]

Thank you!

Yes the first episode is tad bit of a mess, a glimpse of what happens later on, but everything delete is cleaned up. I’m glad you find it interesting!

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Probably no, but there is a chance I would give it a try

What's my opinion
Background is nice, I really like water. Creature looks interesting enough to pick a reader interest.

What can be better
You need to practice human anatomy a bit. I'd say mostly face proportions aren't right and maybe leg position.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your comic journey

[katewindloft]

Scrapyard Castaways | Tapas

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Maybe

What's my opinion
It seems like it's a romance story and those aren't my thing. Overall cover design is nice. I like the b/w stile you got there.

What can be better
Face proportions are a bit off.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your fanfic journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Maybe, I would read description to know what is about and what genre is it.
Could you provide a link to it?

What's my opinion
I like her character design it's cute and princessy at the same time. Roses behind her are getting along well with the whole cover and composition.

What can be better
Her shoulders are to wide for a woman I think. Something about the eyes is a bit odd but can't point what xD, nothing to bad anyways.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.
I updated description for it so it's more clear what is about.

Good luck on your comic journey