Hi, I'm new here and I've just started doing my first webcomic. I started doing it very cartoonish, because it's easy and faster, but I was wondering if it is the most appropiate style for my comic. I'm drawing a romance/fantasy story and here are some examples of my style options.
(That was like the concept art, it turned to be different at the end)
I'm currently using the last one, but I'm not sure which style is more appealing.
I was reading Scott McCloud books and he says that the simplier is your style, is more easy to the reader to indentificate themselves as the character, but I've only seen cartoonish style in comedy comics while the romance ones tend to be more... anime like, or even realistic (Like "True Beauty" and "Siren's lament" from webtoons).
What do you think?
is there an ideal style for each genre?
I know that it would be nice to say "no", but, looking at the facts, it seems that there is one.
EDIT: This is my webcomic: