7 / 13
Feb 2024

I had someone who subbed, liked 5 pages of my novel, and left a sub-4-sub comment. I told them I wasn't going to sub to something if I had no interest in their project, but I did check out their novel for it would be fair, I think - they had a promising story. Yes, that person unsubbed and deleted the private comment on my dashboard.

I browsed their comment history; it was just a bunch of copy-and-paste. Thought it was a bot Tapas failed to prevent from existing, but it wasn't.

Never thought I would encounter one. Saddened to see this person go this route just to get a bigger number.

  • created

    Feb '24
  • last reply

    Feb '24
  • 12

    replies

  • 729

    views

  • 1

    user

  • 27

    likes

I have gotten a few over the years on my profile wall. I just ignore them.
Unfortunately there are real people out there, not bots, who think this is a legitimate marketing strategy.

Yup it's pretty normal, I get a couple every year sporadically.

This is more than common

Back when I promoted new episodes of the Webcomics I work for I had people coming into my DMs, same scheme always:

  • Flatters me and my art a lot
  • Waits for my response
  • Says one two lines about how cool the story is without actually saying anything in particular about it
  • Mentions they are a creator too
  • Demands a sub-x-sub and dumps their link

Sometimes I'm nice and I tell them while I'm flattered I wouldn't sub to their story as it is not of my interest (which is true, none of them has an interesting premise or its even part of my favorite genres)
But other times I directly tell them it feels that they are just complimenting me because they want to create a sense of obligation towards them while offering me to follow their story, just because they sub or compliment me doesn't mean what they do is automatically going to be liked by me.

Still, these cases are less than when I get people asking for free art on my DMs:

  • Someone says hi
  • Compliments my art, about how good it is
  • Wait for my response
  • Instantly asks me to draw for them their incredible story or just that they "need" art from me
  • I share my commission pricelist and what I usually request to draw comfortably
  • Sometimes they just leave me on read, other times they try to get me to pity them by saying how broke they are or that they are students
  • I insist this is my job, and if they are not looking for comics but just art of their ocs, I insist again that this is my job and they could always use Picrew to have art of their ocs for free.

Happen quite often to me, too!
They comment spammed my episodes. Sure, it does sound like they did read my story. But when they asked for a sub right after, it kind of left me feeling... obligated to do so..?

Personally, I'm not mad or annoyed. I'm just happy they tried reading, even with a certain intention behind it.

Honestly, the best way is to not worry about people leaving comments. I've learned over the years that maybe 10% of readers leave the notes that creators long for. The rest of the time, comments have to be battered for (ie. R4R exchanges.) As long as you're getting reads consistently, you're doing good.

You're too kind to check out their series.
However, some people fall for it, then thinking this is a normal way of promotion, and the cycle continues.

Happened to me too not too long ago. Personally, I think it's annoying but I can't really stop anyone from doing it. Ignoring seems the best option in that case.

And to save face for them, I won't mention their names. But they do rhyme with KweenOtaku and theladienred. :smirk:

Yes! :sweat_smile:

I just ignore messages like that. They annoy me too but only a bit, after all, they gave me some extra views and likes.

8 days later

I honestly really don't like sub for sub. It just gets you people who subbed purely to be subbed and don't actually like your story.

I have never got these, but I am new to Tapas. I would ignore though. I read only few novels here and I don't demand sub for sub :slight_smile: I like to choose which novels I read :>

13 days later

I have subbed to one person did a sub for sub but I liked their comic and had gotten current with it, and told them I'd rather them only sub if they liked my comic.

I don't really like the whole sub for sub thing it feels very disingenuous and doesn't mean engagement which is what I really want. I know it probably makes my comic look bad considering how many episodes I have but I feel better about it at the end of the day.

I got one like, two hours after first interacting with the forums. And the guy didn’t even have an original story, just a single, very short fanfic of a piece of media I didn’t even like. That’s double confusing, cause like… ao3 and wattpad are right there, my good sir. Use them.