It's neat that they're making this more of a robust functionality rather than just tiny previews that don't tell you anything, but it's a mistake to go fully visual with no text. It's still going to be too small for people to take in all the elements (and for some people I know to even see in the first place), and without the text accompanying it, it's going to be a worse experience.
It's also kind of presumptuous to ask us to cram all the information necessary, which was formerly divided between the title and the graphic, into a single graphic. A picture may paint a thousand words, but it's not good to put all the eggs in a single basket. Especially when that basket isn't the same orientation as the comic, so a huge amount of creators aren't going to be able to repurpose art they already did for covers. It's asking them to create an original cover JUST for this site, and covers don't really tell anyone enough about what a story is. Covers are to make people interested in looking at the summary, but they don't often sell the whole book.
Unless this is going in the direction that The Duck uses, I don't think this is too massive an improvement. Just inconvenience for everyone, with little likelihood of really improving much of anything.
As a writer this makes me both and
On one hand, pretty much every other publishing site in existence uses rectangle covers so fricken finally I don't need a square cover just for Tapas.
On the other hand, for my Tapas-only series I just recently commissioned a square cover. Which means now I need to commission a new cover or adapt the square one, which means I might be parting with more $$$
But overall, I think the rectangle is a nice change, it mirrors other publishing sites and what actual print books tend to use. I'm just concerned about the apparent lack of text titles while browsing in the screenshot example above. That seems like a major readability issue to me, so I hope they decide to keep the text titles
It just doesn't seem like a very good idea to me, unless they're really planning a comprehensive system of presentation. There are too many variations in production and creation, and fewer people than ever are designing their stuff for print for just so many very pragmatic reasons. Additionally, with the variety of formats out there -- of which a portrait-orientation rectangle is only one -- this whole thing seems designed primarily to force creators to go to this new formatting for one thing at one site.
If it had just been a larger square, most of us probably could have just used a larger-scaled image like the one we use for the Tapas site thumbnail, but it still doesn't tell much of anything about a comic, so it's absolutely going to need more comprehensive presentation for this change or we might as well just not bother.
It will be nice if we don't have to upload a thumbnail for every single update, because that was useless anyway and most of us just used the same thumbnail every time. But if it's just replacing that...well, it's not really much of an improvement. I need to see more details about this whole thing, and right now they've just essentially said "hey we're gonna force you to do this in the next few months, get excited!"
Having seen this kind of thing many, many times over the years in comics...eh. I'll wait to see, but I don't have high hopes for it.
And as noted, there are people who need the text, so it seems pretty inconsiderate to just remove that altogether.
I like the idea I just don't know how I will create one myself. I'm not an artist and right now the ones i create are really basic for my story. For something like that I would want a better cover that isn't basic or simply done. Something that could catch the attention of the readers. So i guess I need to start planning now what kind of cover I would like to make.
Well you can definitely use the cover on other sites too if you plan to upload to anywhere else.
"We recommend working larger at 1920px x 2880px". If you use those dimensions, you can scale it down for Tapas but also use the same cover for, for example Amazon Kindle that apparently recommends 1600 x 2500 pixels for cover size.
@Kaylim
I don't know if this is helpful, but I also have a few covers I'd commissioned with Tapas's square format in mind; this is how I turned one of them into a rectangular cover (not sure if this is final yet, might still play around with it since I feel like the text isn't visible enough):


If this can't work with yours though (certain illustrations don't make much sense anymore once cropped), I agree with @joannekwan 's suggestion; I'll probably also be using this method for covers that can't be zoomed in on.
Alright so I finished a sketch for The Four Friendly Humors. I know its good to make more designs in order to get the best possible, but... idk i already like this. What do you guys think? What should I change to it (keep in mind this is a sketch; i do plan to add color and make the logo not blurry)
Wow I'm all for this change! I was just contemplating how to simplify the cover image for my next story since my original idea for it was too complex. Luckily I hadn't commissioned an artist for it yet lol.
Meanwhile I just revamped my current cover image!
Btw does this mean the size of the thumbnail for each episode of the series is also of the new dimensions?