Rate Your Own Story

[dawgofdawgness]

I rate my comic twelve bowls of oatmeal.
This is because, while the art, composition, and dialogue need work, I think I'm doing alright with characters

[LCT_m_a_d]

My series is 2.5 stars out of 5. I'd say 2 but it boggles my mind that as bad as my work has been there are some people willing to give my series a generous chance. I love my subs. Without them I'd give it a 2 star and probably close up shop lol

[Vikiro_Hop]

I gotta be real honest wit myself here and say that I can only give myself one mario out of a possible total of two marios.

I really need to work on my life drawing a ton. I end up repeating the same poses and perspectives and I think it ultimately dumbs down any sense of dynamics in my comics. Even though it's a gag series I still strive to come up with interesting varied scenarios, so this really get's to me.
And my backgrounds oh god!

I think being in color and having a semi consistent style earns me a mario.

[XzynderVexymous]

Storyline - 5 Stars
Art Design - 2 Stars
Character design 3 Stars

[CPY]

The stories I ever finish writing - 7.5-8/10.

My current comics - 5.5-6/10 (Since I'm not a serious comic maker and only update when I've things to share or when I feel like it LOL)

But oh well, drawing is still fun for me

[darkone4587]

I'd honestly rate my story a six or a hopeful seven, but in my case it's impossible to get a perfect score.

[Agent1Alaska]

Star wise, 2.61 out of 5. It could be better, but I don't spend much time on editing because otherwise it'd take a whole lot longer than a week to write each story. I want to start editing faster, and until I've gotten to that point with a lot more practice, I've just got to hope that one edit will cut it. I'm going to go back and edit my stories in the next month or so to bring them up to at least a 3.47 star quality.

[Wishjacked]

Writing ★★★☆☆
Art ★★★★☆
Characters/Character Design ★★★★☆
Lettering ★★★★☆
How Much I Like It ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★
You Should Read It ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★

Overall, I think my comic is very high quality. Not remarkable or exceptional, but enjoyable anyway and a fun thing to read.

[375]

This is rare to rate your own story. I give mine a maybe a two star for trying

[IdiotWithPencil]

I am a perfectionist and compare myself to monsters regularly so I give myself
a
for art
for character design
for writing

overall score maybe a

and that's just me being generous XD, again I'm comparing myself to monsters of the industry =X and I'm an over critical idiot of my self, I love my comic and hope people will enjoy it too

[hotsubsandwich]

4 for me, Glen Coco!

No but I really don’t know. if I were grading myself I’d probably have like a B+.
It’s too early on in my comic to tell, but the characters are all really developed and have pretty good designs imo. I have a solid grasp on color but I need to spend more time on anatomy. Maybe pacing is weird? Because there hasn’t really been a hook yet and I’m done with chapter one and the main antagonist has only been off-handedly mentioned. But I mean. I love it! Soooo would I read it if someone else were the writer? Hell yeah. Should you read it? Hell yeah.

[NickRowler]

On average...about 3/5.

It's not the worse thing out there and you might be entertained but it's not drop dead amazing either. The art is average and the backgrounds need work. However, I think my strength is creating unusual characters that people can get emotionally invested with even if my writing is a bit clunky.

[NDmangaka]

honestly i would give my art a 9/10 my story 10/10 and my over all score a 9/10
feel free to check it out updates every single week

Rune Symbol | Tapas

[Emma]

Eh, I'll put it at a solid 3/5. I have many places to improve, and I'm not a fan of giving myself a way too high score. However, if you asked me how much I enjoy making it, 5/5.

Story: I guess it's not a too mentally challenging story. I've been told it's cute and a feel-good comic though. And people seem to ship my characters.
Art: Honestly? I could be so much better. I don't challenge myself enough with angles and backgrounds, and it's a constant worry of mine that maybe my pages looks too dull.

Friends or Lovers? | Tapas

[KoreanTacos]

I'll give myself 2 out of five stars, only to motivate myself to improve my skills for 2018, I'll admit I have a couple of strips from 2017 I wasn't particularly proud of.

JODDAS VAPD | Tapas

[GarnetDawn]

dude
I rate mine 5/5 edgy bladed stars that might cut you.

soft and colorful rainbows ★★★★★ extreme edge

seriously though, I'd rate the current episodes a 3/5 normal stars. the missing two being the things I still need to learn and practice about this type of storytelling.

[Chronitis]

Story maybe 3 1/2 stars. For where the story is at right now 1 star. Character personalities 4 stars, and art 2 stars.

The End

[lunaartemisasama]

7/10 or
3.5 stars.

Because I am my own cheerleader.

Here´s my link in Tapas

Chaos Kiss | Tapas

And the one in Webtoons. I can't believe I have a 7.55. Actually that made my day.

Chaos Kiss

[indagold]

I'll give All Broken Gods four bewildered and confused japhins

Felt I kept it short and concise and planned it out better.

Welcome Back one psychedelic cat

Felt I could've planned it out better and not invested so much time into it. Had its good moments but hemmed and hawed too much.

Garden of Mold is just one sad main character because why not.

[punkarsenic]

Five out of five!! My comic is good, guys! I love it so much!

seconded!! your comic rocks

i think id rate my own comic three bc its my first longform (that im planning to finish) and i know theres lots of places i get lost and dont make things clear enough.