Reviewing Comics, Genre Notwithstanding

[Gaspode12]

I would welcome a review of my new comic All Fingers and Thumbs. As it's new I only have 17 episodes posted currently but more are finished and waiting to be posted. Apart from a brief stint many years ago I am new to this sort of thing so welcome any constructive criticism. I am aiming to improve on both the humour and finish of my comic.

[Marton]

I've been looking for someone to review my zombie comic Zotagius. I would be very happy if you reviewed it. It's almost 100 pages long, but it's still in the early stages. On Monday I'll update the comic for the last time before a small hiatus. If you plan to review it, I suggest wait reading until then.

[whovianandwriting]

Hey, my team and I have a plan of a few volumes, and I am halfway through my draft of the first volume. I will PM you the links for confidentiality.

[dglisson]

I would welcome any review of my series, Beast Bait. I'm about halfway through with my second chapter, so there should be enough for you to look at. The second chapter (and first main storyline) will end at the end of the month if you want to hold off until then. It's a supernatural adventure comic in the vein of Doctor Who, X-Files, or Supernatural.

[DeadAccount]

Drugs & Wires is about to wrap up its 2nd chapter and reviews would be great for when we go on hiatus, especially since this is usually the time for me to revise my art and change my workflow around for the next chapter. Thanks for doing this!

[gnekomikero]

I would welcome any review of my manga/comic BOMB A I have 3 chapters done and 4 is still in progress. This is my 1st comic and I was intended to do it one shot for medibang but then I make it into series since I have a lot idea for this! Hope you like it

[jessicasurline]

I am the artist of Whetstone. It is still pretty early in the story but a critique is good for keeping up the quality in the long run. I would appreciate your input good sir.

[Zannen00]

Would love if you can review my comic IMAGICA=verse.
Its a Magic Girl genre (is that even a genre?) so it could be interesting to see how you think about it XD

[alaingrey]

I don't want a review now, but maybe come four months or so I'd be interested to hear your opinions. I know we've shot the shit a lil bit, and you've already mentioned some potential pitfalls you see occurring in my comic, so I'd be interested to see if they are overcame in the future.

Think you'll still be reviewing? <|: )

[Aspie_Gamer]

I give to thee Life of an Aspie for review. I'm currently on hiatus, but I do have one chapter done and about six pages into chapter 2 atm. I'm currently revamping a few pages in chapter 1 especially the first page which looks god awful right now so bear that in mind.

[kristintipping7]

I'd like to see a review of Evil Witch Allie . It doesn't meet your minimum page requirement yet, but maybe you can come back to it a couple weeks from now. I've got the first chapter drawn, but I'm trying to build up a buffer instead of publishing everything at once.

"Jake found little girl claiming to be a witch wandering alone outside his house on Halloween. It would have been nice if that turned out to be the weirdest part of his night."

[jordanthelass]

This sounds like a lot of fun!

I'd love for you to check out Whose World!

Keep in mind, it's a comic-strip; so there's not going to be long story arcs--if there are, they're going to be staggered to keep things from getting boring. That way there can still be character development throughout the series. ^_^

I'm always looking to improve myself and a review might just be what I need to get a kick start in the right direction.

Thank you for your time! <3 I really appreciate it!

[efdvorsky]

I'm always up for good critique and suggestions! Here's mine: Cosmic Fish

It's mostly character driver rather than plot meaning a lot of aspects of the world are purposely kept vague to give this sense of alienation from the characters

[mirokulaw39]

https://m.tapastic.com/series/I-DID-LOVE-HIM#!/subscription/list-recent

I would accept any kind of critique!. Just about chapter 01. Though it is completed, I still want to know what i lack and what i need to improve!
Thanks i advance!
(m_m)!

[phen]

You've gotten quite a lot of awesome comics already posted here (several of these are my favourites, too)! If you're still browsing about for reviews, it would be incredible to get some feedback on There's No Such Thing as Jason -- I.T.! It is a very character-driven psychological drama/fiction limited to just 3 major players at the moment.

Any and all input is deeply appreciated -- from technical skills to story flow to aesthetic appeal. Whatever needs sanding down, I am SO looking to have pointed out for me. My storytelling is my biggest hang-up, something I worry doesn't come off as succinctly as I'd like! The first 20 pages drag (I've been told) so hopefully I remedied that in the next 30, hah! Thanks a ton for your time, and no worries if you can't get to this comic! ^^v

[thesisterscomic]

zombie comic Zotagius

All right, gave this a look. Writing some notes on it now. Given the setting/name scheme, I'm assuming English isn't your native language? It holds up pretty well, but there are bits that sound stilted. I'll comment more in detail once I've given it a more thorough reading. Already made notes, so you're likely up first.

All Fingers and Thumbs.

Is this gag-a-day? Not something I can really comment on immediately, but I'll try to get around to this at some point. I do think there are things to be said about the genre, but I'm biased by my love of The Far Side.

Drugs & Wires

Been meaning to look into that for a bit. I'll mark you for number two.

Whetstone

There's certainly some edge there, but I just read all you had to offer and I think I could definitely say somethings about it. I'll hit you for three.

IMAGICA=verse.

Your art has certainly improved from the start until now. Not exactly my genre of choice, but I've worked in it before.

Think you'll still be reviewing?

If I'm not dead at that point, remind me when you've reached the point you want a review at.

Evil Witch Allie

I'll say this right now. You've got a very good voice and tone set for what is going on prior to this latest page of yours. It is the dissonance that occurs when you shift from that narrative voice to what is happening in the now. It is a little jarring. I'll get to you proper, though I might wait for a few more pages to see if this issue is put to the wayside.

Whose World!

I'm sure I can find a few words.

Cosmic Fish

You've got an interesting concept and I'm liking some of the designs. I'll try to get to you organically.

All right, getting tired of the quote function.
1. Zotagius.
2. Drugs & Wires.
3. Whetstone.
4. Cosmic Fish.
5. No Such Thing as Jason.
6. Various Gag-a-Day/Slice of Life that are not following a story-line.
7. U-Speed, Bomb A, I Did Love Him, Magic Girl genre; mostly because looking at them I feel there will be some overlap in thoughts.
8. Beast Bait, Bite Madness; already have some thoughts percolating on the both of them.
9. Whatever was sent to me privately because I have yet to check my inbox, but I see it there.

Ought to have some done within a week.

[Elliwiny]

Hey! I know you said that your site is outdated, but you've got great insight. This is a really generous offer!

My girlfriend and I are doing a comic called Opportunities, which is about an alien that becomes caught between her murderous ex-bosses and a group of human assassins with their own mad schemes.

We're in the middle of uploading our 8th chapter and rapidly approaching the climax for our first book. I'd really love the feedback, especially since we're reaching that critical point.
I hope you like it!

[R.n.P]

Hey there I would be very happy to here thoughts about my comic THE LAST SAMURAI
Thanks for helping

[TrustyShamrock]

oh my god. i thinks its so nice when people say they'd do reviews and stuff. i would LOOOOVE to have my comic Robo Hole reviewed. and be as straight up as you want to be! i just wanna know whats workin and whats not. itd help me so much for future comic bookings

[Squeakybat]

I'd love a sincere review of my Stellar Persona! I've never gotten a review and I would love some feedback from the community on how i'm doing.