195 / 709
Jun 2018

That’s true. I can imagine that the genre and the type of comic can dictate how much trouble you attract in the comments, even though you don’t have anything evil in mind.
I have established couples (so no ship wars), no politics or social commentary, neither do I address any serious issues which could trigger bad emotions or such. On top of that I’m not that popular, so folks who just want to troll out of spite and jealousy probably don’t even know I exist (let’s hope it stays that way xD)

The worst comment I got so far was a dude who called us stupid when we published a Q&A about our work process. But compared to what I read here about other’ experiences, that’s pretty petty stuff. :sweat_smile:

Oh....interesting...I think I just got hit with the whole down-voting thing on Webtoons and I'm not part of the contest :stuck_out_tongue: Would've had to have gotten around 20 downvotes to knock my rating down that much :stuck_out_tongue:

Thanks for the clear up Michi!
Also I think I'm going crazy but I'm re-reading the rules again and again, and did they...? Change this part?

i was so sure it used to say "no previous existing discover titles allowed, but spin offs and etc allowed" also "self published works also not allowed" and so forth? I can't find this anywhere on the rules, or I glossed over it...

They must've removed that. I remember that part too.
They probably got a lot of mails about it and decided to revise that part :confused:

Hmp I don’t think they ever said no previous existing discover series allowed. If anything I was sure it’s more along the line of “currently existing discover series isn’t allowed to be submitted but you will need to reupload it as a brand new series.” My friend was confused about that too tho so she emailed them and they clarified (in the screenshot I provided) there is no need for you to even take down the currently existing comic on discover, just resubmit it as a brand new series. Or that’s what I gathered.

Also maybe they did change some wording to avoid confusion?

I just saw their tweet they posted 4 hours ago that they updated their FAQ8 LOL ok so I'm not going crazy then.
Thanks for the help on clarification!!

Not joining it. I got enough on my plate with my webcomic AND my printed series...plus, I'm trying to get MORE free time to try to see if I can roll out something on my Patreon at the end of the year.

I'm....I'm going to try LOL
Me and my friend were already working on a new story for this contest, but, after I found out you can submit an existing series, I back-tracked a bit...however I feel like if I wanted to re-submit, I might draw some sort of reboot bc it's kind of my chance to improve it :')
Good luck to you and everyone else in the contest as well :smiley:
(ignore that other withdrawn post lol i somehow posted twice for some reason...)

Wew that cleared thing up and no problem! I’m excited to see everyone’s entires old and new so good luck to you if you joining!

If you're using "Fictional Skin"

You might want to read this:

"7. Can I submit a series that was previously published elsewhere?

You may submit a series that was previously self-published online as long as you fully own the series and have exclusive and direct control over it. You cannot submit a series that was previously published by a publisher (online and/or offline). You cannot submit a series that was previously printed offline for circulation, including self-publishing."

Source: https://www.webtoons.com/en/notice/detail?noticeNo=7512

This pretty much disqualified most of our comics except one which is "Start-Up!"

Oh hey, this is actually what I was looking for! I forgot this part was in the FAQ and not in the rules. It's why I originally opted Fictional Skin out for the contest, and was confused for a sec about their requirements involving previously self-published series. Thanks for the clear up! :smiley:
I sent them an email to ask if re-draws or reboots are ok, despite the self-publication existing, just to be sure.

I did a double take reading the updated FAQ. Wait wait. Just making sure I'm not somehow taking this wrong bc I'm an idiot hyped on adrenaline.

We are allowed to submit old comics from Discover.

We just have to reupload. We ARE allowed to keep the old one up. The only reason we have to reupload is to enter the contest itself. We don't have to change anything about it (unless we chose to revise to make it better).

Okay, this is definitely going to be confusing for readers, but now I'm contemplating improving on Hellish to enter this. 0__0 The only reason I didn't join was because I didn't want to abandon the characters and storyline I put so much thought into (I don't have time to do 2 comics). Ahhhh
Ahhhhhhh

You can enter using "Hellish" but you need to find a smart way to differentiate the two if you are intending to keep both of the same comics.

For us, we just decided to delete the old comic and start fresh. (I don't suggest for you to do this since you will start at zero and lose some of your audience).

Webtoons are just making sure you own 100% of your comic and that you didn't publish it anywhere else under a publisher, online or offline.

@soxu I think someone said earlier that if you resubmit the EXACT same comic WHILE leaving the original up, you need to change the name slightly.

@beta1042 oh okay, gotcha! I saw some people who were submitting their pre-existing discover comic (the exact same one), and they renamed the original copy as "[name of comic] PRECONTEST VERSION]

Would doing something like that be okay? It's just for the sake of differentiating, right?

@soxu That sounds good to me, but I'm also not affiliated with Webtoon in anyway and am not an expert on the rules, I'm just basing my info on what I've read in this thread. So you may want to email them and double check.

I saw a webtoon using the same name, but without caps, they already checked with LW staff before

alright i thought it's because i uploaded a little "thank you subs!" instead of a new episode that my ratings dropped slightly (which could be the case?) but seeing how everyone who got nothing to do with the contest AND have an ongoing webcomic long before the contest was a thing STILL got downvoted to oblivion regardless... i'm starting to have second thoughts, lol.
If only the staff at LW would be more responsive, i'd totally suggest they make it VISUALLY clear which comics are for the contest and which aren't (like put a star icon or something?) I get this is to avoid bullying the contestants, but us bystanders are unfairly getting the heat over nothing, haha!

[ETA] i have just added a note at the top of my description [NOT a contest entry!] juuust in case.... XDDD;;