Fr, I'm looking at this conversation and really only have my own anecdotes to speak on so don't really have any desire to bicker off that, but like... I know my friend's types, and I know a good personality will make them find someone outside of said type really attractive.
I'm into effeminate men (which is already out of the norm) but the guy I'm kinda seeing is not that at all-- nor is he conventionally attractive. Bigger, not that tall, glasses, unibrow, yatta yatta... But idk, I think he's attractive. He makes me laugh, he makes me feel special, he understands me more than others seem to (that might be the shared autistic traits...), he listens and remembers, his passion for things is really cute (even if it's stuff I'm not that interested in), and my cats like him..!
Every time I see folks complain how big a role conventionally attractive play in things of that sort I can only imagine they're projecting their own vapidness onto folks at large. Like, maybe on dating apps, but those are dumper fires in so many ways. Go outside, join a group, and meet people.