6 / 8
Mar 2017

Does anyone have any suggestions on when it's better to just have a series of images instead of an animation or are animations typically better at conveying action and movement.

  • created

    Mar '17
  • last reply

    Mar '17
  • 7

    replies

  • 1.1k

    views

  • 6

    users

  • 2

    likes

  • 4

    links

In my mind animation is limited to very short loops that quickly get annoying. I think great care must be taken when considering the fact that an animation will be viewed on a loop for the entirety of time a reader has the page open. I think that is a cumbersome benchmark, to create something so short, that must be viewed over and over to eternity. I know this sounds crass, but it better be Gainax Jiggle or you're gonna lose your audience.

From what I am understanding is that you wish to use a mix of still images and animations (like in gif format). If so, I think it is best to use them for when you really wish to highlight something, such as a major point of interest in the story. Sort of similar to the impact of there being a single image on page that highlights that particular scene or action. So that could be either a particular point in a combat, death of a character, and so on.

It is all about picking the right time and place. Because from my reading experience, panels that have animations, my attention immediately gets drawn towards that particular scene. So you would really have to plan it out well for a great execution.

I usually use the Tapas app to read comics, and sometimes the animation freezes up. I find it rather annoying to have to wait for my phone to reload to show me the picture. Animations can be just as cool as annoying, so I don't suggest using it that much.

Tapastic's 2 MB limit does limit the length of animation, but I've seen animations nearing 30 seconds, so it's not as limited to just short looping clips. Also on loops, you can create single play gifs so animations don't necessarily have to loop.

I run a comedy comic called Penciled, so there isn't too much of a plot or key plot points.
I've been using animation to express action, but I'll keep this in mind for the future.

I never found animation helpful in comics. Unless it's an animation heavy comic and in a format that works for it, like being posted on a non comic site with embedding or coding for handling it, yes, but mostly a panel or two being animated is distracting. If done well it can work but honestly comics and animations work better separately.

I depends on how you do it. My comic Pecan Pie, deals with it heavily, and honestly, I have yet to have a negative response to it. More often than not, I add some sort of animation. Typically, it's just one panel (but I do have a page that is entirely animated)

Normally, I would not suggest using animation in your comic because if you want to print it out, well, you can't :confused:
But if you don't plan on printing it out, animation can bring something to your page. The one you linked to1 is funny since he just... flies off XD

The issue with lagging is a problem, but it happens for any webpage that deals with video ¯_(ツ)_/¯
So if you are feeling adventurous, then do an animation! :thumbsup: