Would I start reading your comic/novel based on your cover

[Viridis]

Will I click on it?
I think I would give it a try, I like the cover and it gives me a good feeling about it.

What's my opinion?
Hmm, honestly I think your cover is actually really nice. I love the coloring, shading and the overall cover. Looking at it, I think right away it would be on a children's book cover and kids would 100% adore it, lol. Though I don't know how long I would read it since its not really my usual type of comic I'd read. Probably one of those comic I'd read if I wanted something fun, cute and not take too seriously. I love the grass and the character, I think it looks great visually.

What can be better?
I'm not too sure what kind of story this would be. Is this a serious story with a cute fluffy character, and whatever is the plot it makes the story a lot more intense then what most people would originally thought or sign up for. Or is it like up front base of the cover it seem like it would be, but if you actually read it, its actually light hearted, heartwarming and really cute overdrive comic. I can't tell what is the intentions of the comic trying to make itself be?

Side Note
I really hope that you don't take everyone opinion to heart too much. I read though a couple of them. I personally don't know how you would take them of course but I just want you to know, that I think your cover is beautiful, well done and you should be proud to be brave enough to put it out there and to be ask to be given criticism. I wish of everyone who posted and read through that our stories weather they be comic or a novel that they can progress, grow and be able to flourish. Everyone should give it a chance and show what you love and care for be out in the world. Anyways I hope everyone has a good rest of their day, lol. Just wanted to post a cheerful reminder to everyone <3

11:11 On Universe Time | Tapas

[lumisullivan]

Will I click on it
Yes, if I was feeling down and needed something wholesome to read and cheer me up.
What's my opinion
Looks very wholesome and reminds me of the childhood cartoons I watched
What can be better
Well it depends on who you're trying to attract. Right now its giving me young, sweet, cute wholesome vibes, if that's not what the story is about then maybe change it, but otherwise idk.

Here's mine!

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Probably

What's my opinion
I like the character he seems interesting and tittle design.

What can be better
His hair doesn't have free flow it looks forced otherwise it's a cool cover.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.
I changed the cover so now is cell shaded, thanks for your advice on airbrush though.
I'll try shading with different hues to see how that goes.

Good luck on your novel journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Maybe

What's my opinion
I like their expressions while fighting. Two characters in the foreground look like the same one that are fighting which is interesting composition.

What can be better
Forest is out of place here, like it's stick to the foreground. You can divide 2 different pictures with the lines, then it would look better.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.
I don't wanna give to many hints because it's mystery comic. So the mystery can't be really revealed on the cover.

Good luck on your comic journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Probably no

What's my opinion
I'm not into that art style. But I like the male character.

What can be better
Her left eye is a bit to big. Otherwise is great.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.
Thanks for your advice, I changed the cover based on the critiques I got and I'm quite happy that I did that.

Good luck on your comic journey

[greenglasses]

I recognize 2 of the artists in your covers. Did you get their permission before you used those?
If not, there is plenty of free stock photography on the web, so I would strongly reconsider changing your covers.

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Maybe, because of dino

What's my opinion
Font title is amazing and fitting. I also like the background.

What can be better
I can see from cover that you have lot of potential, practice perspective and anatomy and redo this cover when you feel ready. It's not off a lot but it's not good either. I know is hard to learn those things I'm not good at those myself xD

The dino looks really small compared to humans. His head vs body proportion seems wrong, not sure if his head is to big I wasn't studying dinosaur proportions at all xD
There are some things that seems odd on human as well but can't point my finger what exactly. Sorry I can't give detailed critique but I'm learning those things myself so yeah... xD
But overall cover idea is great.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your comic journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Yes, I subscribed and will read it sometime soon. I have lot of them a want to try reading now because of this thread xD

What's my opinion
Wolfie looks pretty scary from the cover. When it comes to animal comic/novels I would check 50% of them xD
But will stick with the ones I really like. You're cover looks great and I want to read it. I especially like b/w choice for colours and how word dog is scratched.

What can be better
Everything sits together so well I don't have anything to point out that can be better.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your novel journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Yes it looks mysterious and engaging.

What's my opinion
Clock mechanism is really fitting for you're novel judging by your description and it seems very interesting. Really want to read it now. xD Which is great.
Cover itself doesn't tell much which is good for some stories. Especially if you don't want to tell to much with the cover.

Good luck on your novel journey

[braincell4rent]

Let´s try

How to survive the worst novel ever written | Tapas

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Maybe

What's my opinion
Cover looks mysterious and doesn't tell much which is good. I like the choice of red font which is same as woman dress.

What can be better
Toastbuster is very small on thumbnail it will be barely visible. There is also some writing on the bottom left which is barely noticeable.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.
You're not that far off, I changed the cover so hopefully now it doesn't look like completely story for children.

Good luck on your novel journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
Fist - no, I don't like drawing style
Second - maybe

What's my opinion
First - looks like a romance story which I'm not into
Second - very scary stuff. I will probably try to read it and see if I like the story.

What can be better
First - Perspective seems off. Shadows are a bit weird on his left hand.
Second - It looks good especially for complex drawing

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your comic journey

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
First - yes
Second - maybe

What's my opinion
First - I like composition and how the tittle is in comic balloon. Characters are giving some kind of impressions of their personalities.
Second - This one seems like a completely opposite kind of story. I didn't even notice shadowy person touching his this is scary...

What can be better
Second - practice blending and shading a bit and it will look better. Also blood can be done better experiment a bit with different brushes and use one that looks the best for what you want to achieve.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your novel journey

[ML_Peregrine]

https://tapas.io/series/How-To-Kill-a-King

Will I click on it
Hmmm, I can't say just from the cover. The title definitely intrigues me though! This looks a bit like one of those historical fantasy novels that have been really popular recently.
What's my opinion
I almost wish there was more on the cover to give us a sense of what the novel is actually about. Like I said, I couldn't make an actual prediction based on the cover. I do think you're on the right track though! Characters on the cover really can sell someone on the novel itself. And overall, I think it's a very pretty design.
What can be better
I really love the cover as it is now, but I do think you can improve it even more by adding a few things in the background to give the reader more of an idea of what the novels about. Since your summary talks about rewinding time, maybe a clock or other timepiece behind her to drive home the point that it's a time travelling story?

Here's mine:

[Nossumy]

Will I click on it
First - maybe
Second - probably yes

What's my opinion
First - Character looks interesting and the cover itself doesn't tell to much but enough to intrigue some people.
Second - I like this one better. He looks like police officer which has dangerous/ mysterious jobs to do.

What can be better
First - His wings are out of perspective, look at some picture of birds to get the idea how wings look from different angles.
Second - Grass could look better.

As for my comic it's a slice of life/mystery, I'm making it so it can be for all ages.

Good luck on your novel journey

[lumisullivan]

This looks a bit like one of those historical fantasy novels that have been really popular recently.

Hahahaha that's exactly the vibe I'm going for

Thanks for the review, I did think of adding something else to the background but I'm afraid it would be to crowded so I decided not to.
Also great minds think alike, you wrote about adding a clock or something aaand actually I do have clock handles in her golden eye, just as a small little eastern egg

[lumisullivan]

As for you cover

Will I click on it
Yes definitely, it's right up my alley.

What's my opinion
Honestly I like it the way it it! It harmonizes perfectly with the title. You can also clearly distinguish between the characters, you'll know who's the mc and who's the king.

What can be better
I truly like this cover so I don't think it needs any improvement in the drawing era. However I noticed that the title is off-center. I don't know, you might like it that way but it's just something I noticed because these thing tend to bug me a bit.

[Toastbuster]

The thing in the corner is just the watermark for the website I used to make the cover lol

[Yuurena]

This is my cover! I hope you like it!

Crossed Arrows | Tapas

[Flauschwurm]

This is interesting

Give me your worst

Morpho Mons - Into a new dimension | Tapas