1 / 12
Dec 2020

It's hard, I posted something on Tapas that was of Romance, but barely gained any views. In the end I resorted to writing BL, deciding it was better to try building a fanbase before attempting try the genre again.

Synopsis: It was her arrogance that led to her loved ones downfall, the fortunate life she had built falling apart before her own very eyes, but a second chance at redemption might be what she needs to piece those broken pieces back together.

I enjoy writing BL, but I would like to try something new.

Basically it was a rebirth romance novel, but I wonder if anyone else that has done the same thing I have?

  • created

    Dec '20
  • last reply

    Dec '20
  • 11

    replies

  • 662

    views

  • 8

    users

  • 29

    likes

Ok, so speaking as a reader, I don't follow authors once they switch to a new genre. I follow an author because I enjoy how they write in the genre they write in and if they were to post in a different genre than one I enjoyed reading by them, I wouldn't follow them over. If you want to build an audience, I would try building an audience in the genre you enjoy writing in because then that audience will for sure follow the rest of the works you put out.

I love romance. I read hetero romance, male/male romance, woman/woman romance, lgbt+ romances. I love them all. As soon as Josh Lanyon has a book up for pre-order, I buy it and anxiously await their release date. Josh Lanyon also has some hetero romance novels under a different pen and I've never even clicked on them because I enjoy the way she writes Male/Male romance specifically.

That's just my take on it though. I'm sure there are also people who follow a specific author no matter what they release.

Edit - reread your first post - are you asking about if anyone has tried to build an audience in BL then switch genres or are you asking if anyone has written a rebirth romance novel? I might have answered the wrong thing

No, you were correct I was gunning more towards if my readers enjoyed my writing for my BL novel, then they would check out something else I had posted–maybe even bring an influx of readers with the BL novel.

It's pretty hard to bring attention to a romance novel, especially since there are so many already written.

That's interesting, I've never heard of Josh Lanyon before I'll go check them out.

The Adrien English series are my all time favorite male/male romance novels, but her current The Art of Murder series is REALLY good too! Also 'The Ghost Wore Yellow Socks' is pretty great by her

I actually have troubles getting audience or ranking in popular or trending in BL. There are a lot of books with huge following there, so it is hard to get noticed. Romance category was far kinder to me.

Theoretically, yes, I understand that most readers come to Tapas to read BL, but it’s hard to stand out in BL

That's very interesting, I didn't realize–maybe it's because our circumstances were so different.

I dunno, I posted a hetero romance in August-October and I am posting BL in Nov-Jan. My hetero often got into popular, while BL is pretty much never... trending is not my category in either, I mostly get silent readers :innocent:.

I am not sure what hurts my BL. It has good formatting, proper chapter length, decent grammar and a solid plot. I am guessing the Russian theme or something. Who knows. But anyway, for me BL wasn’t a ticket. I mean, I wish it was as easy as ‘just write BL’. I would have been writing BL all day long.

Everything is always a crapshoot! Might as well enjoy what you're putting time into creating.

While BL is popular, the competition is also very steep, especially on Tapas. Same goes for any popular genre on any platform.

I say just write what you like. I've spanned many genres with my comics and novels from paranormal slice of life sitcom to a serious mxm romance to an erotic historical fantasy het monster romance. Sure building a solid, instantly-recognizable brand is harder, but over time your brand will be more defined by things that are slightly less tangible, like style, themes, and voice.

I will note the fans that carry over from one story to the next regardless of genre are the best though! Some people just come to appreciate the way a creator looks at the world, how they interpret things, their way of telling a story, etc.
It's like how game companies can gain a following despite making games in completely different settings. Bioware's got fantasy and sci-fi. CD Projekt Red's got fantasy and cyberpunk. Rockstar's got gangsters and cowboys.

There's no reason why you can't write in several different genres. Many authors do. I'm not a big fan of really scary horror so I don't read Stephen King's horror, but I do enjoy his fantasy.

You probably, if you switch, will not retain certain readers for a different genre, but if they'll come back for the genre they like.

I write in just about all genres (except romance, I suck at that). Not here but elsewhere I have people who like my mysteries and then I have people who like my more adventure type things.

You're an author, write what speaks to you.

Remember, Stephen King writes some of the best fantasy around but most people know him for his horror.

Write hard, write true.

There's a lot of BL and romance novel and comic out there, which is why it's not actually easy to building fanbase out of those 2 except you have something inside the storyline that makes you look different than another title.

I mostly read for the characters and story. If an author I like writes in different genres/romance pairings, then I'll check out their other stories. As long your audience isn't just in it for the BL and only the BL, then I think you'd get some following across genres.

Since someone else mentioned Josh Lanyon, I like her stuff in general, but I think the romance is lacking. She's a 'see if kindle or the library has it' author for me because it is that hit or miss. I liked her Adrien English series in general, but I enjoyed CS Poe's Snow & Winter series better (which is inspired by Adrien English, and for me has a lot less of the things in it I didn't like about Adrien English).

There will always be a certain genre that will be popular and eventually it will change to something else, that's true for most things. But there's no reason why you can't write something else to you don't want to!

I'm currently writing a romcom and it's typically not what I write, but I'm having a blast with it and I'm discovering that maybe, I am slightly funnier than I initially gave myself credit for. :sweat_02:

Bottom line: if you write something that you're not interested in, it's probably going to reflect in your writing. And building a fanbase starts with a quality product. Focus on your craft and the rest will follow!