1 / 89
May 2020

Welcome back, True Believers! The old thread was getting silly being over 100 posts long, so this is thread 2!

At the end of that thread, I made a document summarising a lot of stuff you might find useful, so maybe give that a look while you wait in line for a slot or your review!

And now... THE RULES!

  • Only submit when there are slots open. I accept groups of 5 at a time. If you missed a chance at a slot and want a ping when I'm opening them again, post to say that or PM me. Occasionally I'll give an extra 6th slot to a deserving person who keeps missing slots. If somebody gets one of these, they usually deserve it. Don't ask for one.
  • Submit ONE Tapas comic. No novels (there are other threads for that). I'd prefer to read on Tapas over Webtoons if you're hosted on both. I'd really prefer Tapas only but... rgh I'm too softhearted to rule other platforms out completely because I do understand webtoons apparently has no forum (boo! Forums for life!).
  • Your comic must have at least a cover and either five episodes or equivalent to 5 print pages worth (assuming a "page" is approx 4+ panels) of content.
  • I will not re-review comics I reviewed last thread. But I will review new comics by people who had comics reviewed last thread if they meet the page count.
  • I don't do private reviews via PM or email.
  • I reserve the right to decline to review any comic. I've so far not needed to do this, but in the case of extreme nudity, gore or disturbing themes, I might decide I'm not the right person for the job because I'm sensitive to that kind of thing.
  • Other people in the thread are welcome to review comics I decline, or to follow up with advice directed at helping those reviewed so long as they keep it in the helpful and positive spirit of the thread (In the last thread, everyone was great! Good job, peeps!).

These are creator-facing reviews intended to give you guidance and direction to make your comic more market-friendly and hopefully boost your comic's ability to be discovered and to pick up subs and maintain audience engagement. They are not audience-facing reviews designed to tell you what's a good comic to read. I'd recommend the reviews more for people stuck under 250 subs because they'll get the most out of it.

The criticism of your comic is not a criticism of you as a person and your comic's sub numbers don't tally your value as a human being. It is 100% okay to feel upset after a review, because I know criticism is a bitter pill to swallow. I always feel upset after reviews and criticism and usually need to cry it out in a dark room for a while before I can respond in a professional and polite way! :sweat_02: So just know that I am entirely sympathetic to this. I'm on your side. I respect the hard work you've put in regardless of your experience and ability level. So please take the critique like a grown up and be polite. You don't have to agree with what I advise you to do, but please keep your mind open to change and don't flame me out or be dismissive of everything I say after I've spent hours going through your comic making notes. You know what to expect from the last thread. You will probably not be the magical exception for whom I have no criticism. I will try to help you as best I can and be nice and compliment you when you've done good, but it may be a bit like a trip to the dentist.

And with that... LET'S GET DOWN TO BUSINESS!

Paging @Hot_Coffee I said I'd offer you a slot in that other thread a while back! Feel free to take it, or ignore if you're not bothered. :smile_01:

  • created

    May '20
  • last reply

    Jul '21
  • 88

    replies

  • 7.7k

    views

  • 31

    users

  • 204

    likes

  • 41

    links

Frequent Posters

There are 88 replies with an estimated read time of 56 minutes.

Here is my comic called Ignis Somnia, it's based around the world of esports. The first chapter is more than five pages.

dunno if you will find this suitable - its' a bl sorta story but no extreme nudity - just shirtless boys and some kiss(es) , and ist rather lighthearted not earnest

ty for the doc it seems very detailed - i'll check it out thoroughly after work!

Hi! Please check mine out if you'd like to, I hope it's suitable <3

I think it’s really amazing what you do for everyone. It takes a lot of time to do reviews and you clearly put a lot of thought and heart into yours :blush:

I really like the way you review too! It’s effective to even follow along with you. Thanks for all your hard work!!

Kisses, shirtless boys, that kind of thing is fine. No problem! Also no problems with any and all LGBTQIA+ types of content. :flag_white:️‍:rainbow:

The content would really need to be very very very smutty (as in, it needs to be in the mature tag) for me to maybe be like "oof, this is too spicy for me" on grounds of sexy stuff. I'm more likely to decline a comic based on violence or upsetting themes.

@alzbetarudisova nothing looks unsuitable here at a glance! :smile_01:

I really wanted to try and get input after chapter 2 from someone with as thorough reviews as you but that’s like a year away so I might as well learn what I’m messing up now!

I can't remember if you've given me a review or if I've posted to something like this. My memories bad .3.

So feel free to reject me or something if you have or don't want to. ^^'

I think I've given some feedback on another thread months ago, but not a full review? So sure, I can review this?

ALL SLOTS FILLED (but @Hot_Coffee there's a 6th slot just for you if you want it). More will open after I review this batch.

Please give it a shot!

Thank you for this incredible service, really you are amazing.

I won’t be submitting a comic, I just wanted to say thank you.

So I know you said you wouldn't re-review comic you reviewed in that last thread and you can say no to what I'm asking. If this thread is still available when I finish my redraw/rewrite of my first chapter and a slot is open, would you be willing to review and critique that for me. Just the first chapter, nothing more. If you don't think that's unfair to other people wanting reviews since you already reviewed my comic for me, I understand. I just wanted to ask. :blush:

I think that sounds reasonable and I'm happy to allow it. I've noticed you getting some good critiques from a variety of threads, so I'm interested to see what you create. :smile_01:

Oh thanks so much! I hope you know yes all really appreciate the time and consideration you put in to help others in this thread. Your advice really means a lot. Thank you! :grin:

Just wanted to pop in to say I love your reviews/critiques, and how I'm in awe of your dedicated to keep up your thread in spite of it being such a time consuming, thankless task! Also I appreciated the Google doc you put together, I'm sure a lot of time went into it.

If you're still running a critique thread by the time I start working on a child friendly, light-hearted comic, (and you have open slots.) I would love some of your feedback.

Aww man, been away from the forums. I'll try and get in there for the next batch. Not ignoring you, sorry!

Hey! There you are! You get a special 6th slot! :smile_01: I'll do your comic after I finish these first 5 but before I open for submissions again!

Oh nice, thanks a lot! I'll just leave the link here.
You're too kind!

My first comic may have been put on hiatus, but I'd be interested to post in a thread like this sometime this year.

Also, I think you and @IndigoShirtProd are alike when it comes to in-depth reviews!