1 / 5
Jun 2021

Just looking for some feedback on my webtoon. I've maintained a solid rating of 9.95 after 17 chapters but I get very few comments so I was wondering if I'm doing something wrong. Maybe I'm in the wrong Genre? Any feedback is welcomed along with your comic if you're looking for the same!

  • created

    Jun '21
  • last reply

    Jun '21
  • 4

    replies

  • 399

    views

  • 3

    users

  • 4

    likes

  • 1

    link

I took a look at your first three episodes and I would have guessed that based on the title and the style that this would be in the Comedy/Romance genre. I can also see how Slice of Life could work but I would really reconsider Fantasy as a genre. You can also try the "Heartwarming" genre since it seems like a very lighthearted comic, and it's a much smaller pool of comics that you'd be competing with.

I think the reason you might be getting few comments is because the storytelling needs some work. People can't comment on things they don't understand, and I was kind of confused reading the beginning of this. I didn't know why the characters were doing what they were doing, and you introduced so many of them all at once. I also noticed that the pacing seems a lot better in your latest episode, so I'd consider updating your first few episodes - even if it's just to put more space in between the panels. Your art is really clean and expressive, I just think the pacing/storytelling can be improved and you'll get a lot more attention.

Thanks, I've been playing around with genres a lot lately to see if I'm in the right place. Originally it started as an SOL/Romance but I've been everywhere with it. The first three chapters will be updated over the summer as I got to chapter 3 I realized it may not look as good on phones with readers so it's defiantly on the list. Thanks for your feedback!

Off topic but I don't think you should focus on your rating, for webtoon, the rating system is not very good and accurate of measuring how popular or good/bad your comic is. I've even seen a few comics get harassed where people mass rated popular comics with low star.

I had a rating of 10 for at least a month or so until it dropped to 9.75 because one person rated it low. So it can fluctuate a lot, especially for lower subscriber number. It looks like you have about 7-800 subs which is pretty good, so ratings will pretty much even out the more popular it gets. So while your rating is good, it doesn't reflect the actual viewership and activity so you don't have to be worried if it drops.

Ah, that makes sense since I'm only a few months into this webtoon rating/views/subs I have no idea how to gauge it lol I figured if my rating was still high it must mean people like it enough not to trash it. I just recently found out that the views are page views, not even people that have viewed it so that misconception threw me off even more. Thanks for the comment.