Red: Penne alla vodka with a hint of basil
Blue: Medium rare ribeye steak with garlic mashed potatoes and steamed broccoli
What a cool idea for a game! Lot's of good answers. I'll answer as one of my Lycan characters, Timber.
"So it was after a long hunt. We had just snagged our quarry, and were tired, but flushed from the hunt. It was a full moon. Marsh gets.. frisky... on full moons. But we had been hunting all day and I was HUNGRY. So I cooked up my questing special, a bird I killed and cooked! I call it, cooked killed bird! And we ate it."
"What? No I don't remember what kind of bird it was. Why was this my favourite meal? Oh, cause mid way through, Marsh lost patience and pounced on me, and while I had a mouth full of meat, she also had a mouth full of... well anyway, and then some stuff happened. A lot of stuff... Yeah, that was a great meal."
I really loved your description of the dish, great job! Kôra definitely sounds like someone who has really experienced something with the way that they describe the soup.
Hunger is the best seasoning.
Bookist: "Knowledge is really the best food and that's why I share all these books, come pick one... Aside from that, when I was part of this insane cult we once got a bag of some fruit as an offering. We were not supposed to eat them, but I was hungry and it looked juicy so I helped myself to one of them. It was very soft and sweet, with a slight punch of earthy smell and fresh green leaves. It also made me sleep and dream, after which I decided to leave the cult... One day I will tell you what was the dream"
"What is the best food you ever ate?"
Amari: Coffee.
Yangyang, in the background: Coffee isn't a food...
Amari: It's a stupid question. All food is equally good.
Yangyang: Says your black hole of a stomach.
Amari: Then what's your answer?
<Yangyang's eyes scan Amari and he chuckles>
Amari: Why are you laughing? ...Don't.
Yangyang: My ba made the best scallion pancakes. I really miss those. <smirks> Why? What did you think I was going to say?
Amari: Shut up.
(It's actually a sweet story, but I have a dirty mind, so...)
Fun topic!! Ok, here goes!
Bally, average suburban high school teenager: The best food I ever ate? Oh, it's gotta be that peanut butter chocolate shake from that one place on the way to- no, actually the chili fries from Tally's are the best! Yeah! But wait, more than that, there was this really awesome burger stand and-" (continues to go on and on 
)
"What was the best food you ever ate?"
Alice - "before or after I was transformed? Before, behmian boar, love the taste. After? Probably human flesh. What? Why are you looking at me like that? You wanted me to be honest."
Wow, Franz, that description of the fruit is great. I could almost taste it. It also makes me curious about the Bookist. Great work!
Alright! Let's do this!
Agony: Uh... I found a box a' brandy filled chocolates after The End. That was pretty great.
Thesis: Hm? Oh, I don't know. Before The End it was a lot of the same day to day. I'd have to really think about it.
Duenna: Oh, cranberry scones. I used to pack them for school with me as a girl. and then when I started teaching I started doing it again.
Motif: Fruit tastes awesome when you're on acid.
Sequel: (says nothing)
Motif: (gestures at Sequel) He said something about liking sammies at some point.
"What was the best food you ever ate?"
I'll respond as my MC, Cinna.
"Trees."
"Please don't judge me, but yes, plain white, plastic trees are the best food to have ever graced my lips. I've realized a few years ago that perhaps I should stop eating them."
What was the best food you ever ate?
Seth: Ooh hmmm that's hard to say! There are so many good ones!! If I had to choose though...uhh...oh! - those sugary thingies that we got from the fair! They were called...what were they called-"
Joyce: "I think you're talking about funnel cakes. We got some when we went to the local fair for the first time. It was right after we went to the petting zoo I think"
Seth: "Yeah! Funnel cakes!! So good...What about you, Joyce?"
Joyce: "oh- um... I guess...apple pie?"
Seth: "...you guess?"
Joyce: "I-it's hard to say really...too many choices y'know! haha..."
What was the best food you ever ate?
Bjorn: "Well that's easy - mead of course! I remember the first time I..."
Korr: "Um...Capt'n"
Bjorn: "Oh what is it now Korr? Can't you see I am in the middle of answering this man's question."
Korr: "Yes, of course Capt'n but...you see, mead isn't a food. "
Bjorn: "Ha! Now is not the time Korr, to be making such ridiculous jokes. Um...now where was I?
...Ah, yes now I recall... and that is when I found out that squirrels make terrible house pets."
Wen : Well all food is good food, unless its rotten, or burnt, or both... and no to cannibalism, and also no capsicum, rest is good food. And no raw meat. yeah. that's all.
Just a character from my book.
Hello everyone, it has been a couple of days and I am still making my way through all the wonderful responses and checking out everyone's comics. I want to make sure I respond to each post made in the thread. It may take a little time, but it is what it is. The food question was quite interesting and I saw a lot of great posts that really conveyed a lot of character. This is looking to be a fun way to hone in on the voice of a character as well as promote stories.
In particular, my favorite post in the first round was by @diamondpowder; they sure can describe a delicious bowl of soup!
However, now we're onto a new question. Are you ready?
Question #2 (in character response, please): "What is the most embarrassing thing to ever happen to you as a child?"
I'll go first with my werewolf, Fang:
"When I was a child I came from a rather poor fishing village on the shores of Lake Triseria and there tended to be a lot of, well... fish guts out and about. All over the beach and the docks, and in the alleys between the houses. Well, I was a bit of a scrapper in my youth, always pick fights. I made the mistake of picking a fight with an older boy... [Fang pauses] Torel, I think his name was. We started wrestling near the big fish house, where they gut the fish to salt and seal them in the jars and pots. I may have been a fighter, but I wasn't necessarily a good one, back then. Wasn't even a big kid, either. About a minute or two in, Torel just picked me up - my arms flailing and smacking at him, mind you - and dropped me into a trough of fish guts that were pouring out from the house... [Fang chuckles] I smelled like rotten fish for about a week or so."
Adiael, wood elf huntress and adventurer: "Most embarrassing childhood event? Oh, being denied access to divine magic in front of my entire village, and then never receiving a reason WHY? And being literally the only person anyone had ever even heard of to have that problem? Yeah, that was pretty mortifying. Who, me, bitter? Don't be ridiculous..." (snarls bitterly)
(BTW, this EXACT scenario is playing out in the prologue!)
What was the most thing you've ever done as a child?
Alice: I don't know I was rather a good kid. I guess one time I walked up to a magic user and asked them if they could show me a spell. I got whipped for that and Mama was absolutely terrified.
Sandra: Too many embarrassing things! I remember there was once I forgot to lock the bathroom door. My mum's new boyfriend of the week came in and there I was, naked. It was shudders a terrible feeling. 
Alist Glassheart:
"There wasn't anything embarrassing that happened to me when I was a little orphan in my past life because I lived under the wrath of abusive orphanage guardians but ever since I transmigrated into my favorite novel, I can't get used to my new parents' antics.
The most embarrassing thing that happened to me in my childhood is sleeping beside my parents who happen to be making love in front of me. I mean, I transmigrated into a toddler in the novel so obviously I retained my 18 years of intellect and conscience. From all the moaning and sweating, it seems as if they have forgotten about me. Must-have transmigration travel items: EYE MASK and EARMUFFS! 
."
Aerith: "So many embarrassing things happened to me when I was younger, but I think the most embarrassing is when some the other girls at the orphanage I was staying at teamed up to prank me, and got away with it. This "epic prank" of theirs lasted a whole day, consisting of starting food fights targeting me, stuffing my pillow with tacks, finding loopholes in the rules during sports to humiliate me, and so many other horrible things. Since I didn't really talk to anyone, everyone thought of me as a target. I'm glad I left that hellhole when I did, I was sick and tired of people treating me like trash."
What is the most embarrassing thing to ever happen to you as a child?
Pom:
"So, this one time I tried to pull a prank on the queen of pranksters, Rebecca Curse. Shoulda known that wouldn't turn out too well but I'm not exactly known for being smart so there. Either way, she found out in no time and actually dared me to do it, in full view of everyone. So I dumped a whole bucket of reeds down the back of her hoodie, in full view of everyone, including my teacher and the principal when he was walking by. Once again, let me say that I'm not exactly known for being smart.
Afterwards, I was chased by my teacher's sawblade equipped drone for a solid fifteen minutes around the school. He keeps telling me that the sawblades are made of rubber but I once saw him using that thing to cut down a whole tree so I'm not falling for his bullshit. And on top of that, I was suspended for two days afterwards. And on the tippety top of that, Rebecca dumped a whole bucket of reeds down the back of my coat while we were walking home from school, when no one was looking.
No wonder she's a straight A student while I'm stuck with my D's."