6 / 6
Sep 2021

Hey! I've been working on my web comic for a few months, and my art has improved so much since the beginning... this means that the first couple of chapters look very bad compared to the newer ones.

I was wondering if it was worth it if I was to redraw the first few episodes...

Here is some art from the first couple chapters... These will contain a lot of spoilers for my comic so...

and here is the art for one of the newer chapters...

Should I redraw the first few chapters?

Here is the comic if you want to see

  • created

    Sep '21
  • last reply

    Sep '21
  • 5

    replies

  • 767

    views

  • 4

    users

  • 11

    likes

  • 2

    links

In my experience, it's almost never fruitful to go back and redraw the first few episodes this early in. You should be focusing on continuing your story, more so than anything and once you complete the comic, maybe then consider going back and making edits.

Part of the appeal of webcomics is not only the fact that you watch the artist and art for the comic grow in real time, but also that the comic updates a little each week or month and you get to stay invested over a longer period of time because of that. (There's also an idea that folks get attached to that original product-- think about how angry people were when the original Star Wars was re-animated over with new nonsense... it's a bit like that. Even if you think your product is humble, folks will still get attached.)

I see a LOT of folks who "restart" their webcomic like 5, 6, and so on many times and never get past a certain point because they're obsessed with ALL of the art being consistent-- which just isn't possible for a one person team and tends to slow down products. I think just continuing forward is best! Having your comic actually get done is worth more than any super polished art, imo.

That said, going back and making small edits like making bubbles more readable or adjusting text or fixing an inconsistency usually feels fruitful because it improves those older episodes without you having to put in like, A TON of extra work or interrupt your current update scheduale. But even now, your first episodes are perfectly readable, I see no reason to go back and edit them.

Your art will always be improving an changing, there's no reason to keep going in a loop trying to keep it all on and up and up, moving forward and continuing to update is the most important thing for webcomics, imo.

That's just what I've observed and dealt with though, take my advice with a grain of salt. If you feel passionately about remaking the pages and you feel like it'll be fruitful for you-- then GO HOG.
Good luck!

Thank you so much for this! I think I will definently just keep on going with new chapters. I think I will keep the first few chapters as they are, just for a reminder of how much I have grown! Thank you again!

Just seconding (or thirding?) the don't redraw. I really wanted to a few months in and now that it's been a year and a half I'm really glad I didn't waste my time :smile_01:. I'd just have wanted to redo it again. Enjoy the improvement!!!