26 / 238
Oct 2015

I think the one on the right is better, because the plain boxes don't draw your eyes away from the pictures, whereas on the left, they are distracting.

Thanks for the feedback. I ended up going with something kind of inbetween. Basically just doing thin boxes but then going over it with a thicker and intentionally messy black line. Im satisfied with the look now smile

It also lets me augment the emotion I want to deliver in a panel by drawing the borders messier and uglier depending on what the character is expressing. Check out my comic4 if you want to see what I mean smile

You kept the feel of the thicker boxes, whilst not taking too much attention from the pictures inside.
I like it -- it has the best of both box types.~ (>uo)

29 days later
18 days later

hello everyone! I am trying to decide on the main title typeface for my comic Reus5, but I'm having a hard time finalizing on which one I like best. What do you all think looks the most appealing? 1,2,3, or 4?


I know they are all similar, which is part of the reason I'm struggling =_=
Here2 and Here3 are some banner images with the fonts I have used thus far. There's nothing particularly wrong with either of those fonts--in fact I quite like them. But I wanted to create something a little more unique/memorable.
thoughts??

p.s. I've only included the font-aspect for now. I will add other elements (e.g. symbols and the like) once I've decided which of the four I like best!

I would go with #4. Looks easier to read compared to the others.

I would go with 3 as it has the space as logo number 4 yet doesn't have the large s that closes the smaller case letters. The small s could go with a bit more line thickness as the s is harder to read.

I like number 1 because it's a lot more stylized than the others. However the other ones are easier to read, so I think 3 would be the best one smile The space in 4 makes it look a little too scribbley, 3 is sort of the happy medium IMO.

23 days later

I like this! And if it's a style you're comfortable with, I say go for it! It kinda reminds me of a mix between All This Doubt and awut. Very nice! ~ <3

I'm pretty confortable with this style. I made it in a way I can draw fast, because I don't have much time.
I'm happy that you liked it smile

Hey! Since my switch from b/w to color pages, I've been trying to tweak things a bit to help tone down the digital look. So far I've got this(below). Is that better, worse, or do you guys have any other suggestions? Thanks in advance!

Current Page 5:

Slightly Tweaked Ver.

I like the slightly tweaked version better. They're both well done, but I think the second one is more interesting. It adds texture and matches the gritty western theme you seem to have going.

Thanks for the help! I thought the same thing myself, but I was also worried a bit about adding too much too it. Looks like I've got some thing new to add next chapter! ^^

I think I actually prefer the first one, the characters seem to stand out more and it looks cleaner. If you are going to use the second method I would recommend reducing the grain on your points of focus. (e.g. the walking character and the fellow with the red hat)

Very true! It's all on another layer, so I just need to lower the opacity some more and it should be good. Thanks for the help, Young Adventurer!

Hey people!! I need to know which side is better so I can include it for my next update. The one to the left is my original concept, but I don't know what would look good on Tapastic's comic page. Thank you for the help. Peace. :))