6 / 9
Mar 2016

A lot of times when I finish a strip I wonder if the joke will work on an audience. Is the punchline good enough? Will enough people get it? Or will it fall flat on my readers. Well, a quick way to find out is to post it on imgur and see what happens. If my comic gets a slew of upvotes in about ten minutes then I delete it and know I have a winner on my hands. If the downvotes and hate come raining on my parade, then I know I have a problem. Sometimes the comments can even be helpful. Like maybe there was some confusion with the strip, or the punchline just wasn't good enough. Regardless, it can be a quick way to gauge how your latest strip will fare with a real audience.

  • created

    Mar '16
  • last reply

    Aug '16
  • 8

    replies

  • 1.6k

    views

  • 1

    user

  • 6

    likes

I tried to post something funny in imgur. well sometimes there are bias who just like to down vote anyway somehting like that. and when i repost again there many upvotes. so im not sure i think it depend on timing and how you caption it.

Interesting idea, but @gnekomikero is right, there could be some bias depending on what people get to see it. If the joke is safe for children, you can ask a younger brother, nephew or any kid at your disposal, they won't trash it out of malice nor lie to protect your feelings.

I suppose like any "study" you need to repeat your test a few times to see if you get similar results. I've posted the same comic twice to radically different results depending on the time of day, but at least I can see there is potential there. However If every time I posted soemthing there and it bombs then I know it's a bad strip and no amount of proper timing will help it.

Just show it to someone in real life and look at their reaction to it. If they snicker or laugh at the right time, then you got it. If they laugh at something you didn't expect, ask what it is, and take it to heart.
If there's no reaction, I say there could be something wrong. That's when you can ask for advice. I often have one of my guys look over my writing (or my sketches) before doing the final inks. Eventually you might get to the point where you don't need anyone else's input, but even the greats often tell their jokes to their kids.
Real life feedback is incredibly valuable. Much more than over the internet, mostly because it can be hard to gauge what is good or not.

I've been testing this myself now on a couple of comic panels. You can get feedback real fast, but one problem is the hive mind mentality that will occur. The more downvotes you get, the bigger the chance that more people will give downvotes or not vote at all. And if you get upvotes fast, people will join in giving upvotes, thinking that there is something brilliant going on, even if they don't get it.

That's why cat videos rule Youtube and the reason Donald Trump could be president one day.

Edit: This sounded a bit negative. My experience with imgur has been a positive one, and I do think you can use it to your advantage if you understand how the game plays out.

2 months later

Funny is subjective.

I'd recommend you concentrate on writing something you enjoy rather than trying to identify with some sort of audience. If you enjoy the process and what you are doing it will resonate and an audience will find it eventually with patience.

So do it for you and the rest should work out, I reckon.

(post withdrawn by author, will be automatically deleted in 24 hours unless flagged)

2 months later

I agree with showing it to someone in real life. Online people can easily type 'LOL' with a straight face.
Yesterday I showed my mom an upcoming scene in my comic. My mom doesn't read my comic since she doesn't know english for which I'm glad since it's a BL comic and I know she'd be against it. But she saw me drawing this certain scene and asked me to translate it for her and she laughed so hard, so I assume it must be pretty funny O_o