15 / 31
Nov 2016

My initial attention is grabbed by an interesting art style. And it doesn't have to be super-polished or extremely technically accomplished - I read comics that other people might think look like children's scribbles. It just has to be interesting and suit the story they're telling.

What keeps my attention is a combination of good artwork and a solid storyline, or themes I like, or character-types I enjoy, etc. I was working on a pitch for a comic of my own earlier this year, and wrote myself a reminder-list of stuff I like in stories, and it lists things like "found families", "inevitable doom", "unexpected triumphs", "female friendship", etc., etc. So there are a lot of hooks to throw out for a creator to catch me on.

But like @Michelle and @shazzbaa said - a comic gets a limited number of pages for me to get interesting. If, by page 10, it hasn't shown some glimmer of potential, I drop it. If by page 10 there is something there, but it hasn't found its legs yet, I'll give it to page 20. If it still isn't finding its tone by then, I'm likely to drop it. I'm a very picky reader, so a lot of good comics don't make the cut for me.

For me it's mostly art style that gets me interested. I like art styles that are pretty unique, stylish, and out there and won't always keep reading if the style doesn't grab my interest. It's EXTREMELY rare for me to get interested in a story if I'm not into the style. (not saying I won't read anyway, especially right now when I'm trying to focus on making connections with folks regardless of their style, but once I'm more settled it'll probably be more rare since I just don't have that kind of time to keep up with stuff I'm not feeling)

Subject matter also matters a lot to me. There are a lot of genres I just straight up don't care about. They could be the most well written thing in the universe, but it'll be very hard for me to care about it simply because of the genre. Give me something from a genre I love and it won't matter how stupid the story is.

I've just seen so many films and ready so many books and played so many games that I kinda hit a point where I'd just rather see things I don't feel like I've already seen a thousand times over.

Also the weirder it is, the better. So basically, if it's weird, has a unique style, and isn't a genre I dislike, you'll have my attention. If you don't, though, it DEFINITELY does not mean it's a bad comic or anything, nor would I call all the ones that do, good. I just have very specific preferences that a lot of comics just don't hit the mark on.

My soul is sold to a series when I find that one character that I love. There are many cases when I picked up a series just because I happened to stumble upon a character somewhere that was visually pleasing, and I wanted to know more of them immediately XD
That one time I suffered through a Visual Novel with a genre that I disliked with elements that I disliked even more, but I was rewarded with knowing more about that one guy that caught my attention, so I (almost) don't regret reading through it. (cannot unsee some disturbing stuff)

Amen!
It's boring and frustrating to see a lot of repeated art styles, even if story and writing are great

oh man, i would have to say that when the art work creates a very clear flow, and intentionally leads the eye all over it, so you naturally are drawn to look at the whole image. I find that I really speed through comics that don't have this and end up missing a lot of the story, but when you get the artists that do think about it, it doesn't even matter how technically good their art is, i'm still looking at all the details and really taking in the whole story!

it has to have just the right amount of text and something that will make me go ha!

My attention is caught by an interesting art style - doubly so if it has strong composition and color theory! However, great art will not save a weak story and hollow characterization. If it's not well written AND well lettered (for real, the more I've learned about lettering the more I get REALLY put off by sloppy lettering work) that comic gets put down and likely never picked up again.

What I look for most (in any story-telling media, really,) is probably a creative world-setting and good characters. It doesn't necessarily have to be a far-out fantasy or sci-fi world. Even modern-day earth (like) settings can be original. For example, Kurisquare's Postcards in Braille seems like a normal modern day setting, but there are some unique aspects, like a cultural trend to name children after Greek letters, and "Composer!" as an exclamation (their word for God). There are also other elements that hint at a world setting that is deeper and more creative than just 'modern day, earth as we know it'.
Good characters are also important, in my opinion. Those who are likable, relatable, interesting, sympathetic, or with some kind of plot hook aspect to them. There are many way to make a character compelling.
A good story line is also a big plus, although not all stories are plot-centric.
Quality artwork is also important, but honestly I'd rather read a good story with average artwork than a boring story that is well illustrated.
But that's just me.

i think when art is doing something different, that really catches me - like hiddenfolk's2 linocut style or the dynamic angles and poses in spire. when its not just nice to look at, but interesting. as a nerdy artist, thats the key to my heart.

also, honestly, lesbians. anything with lesbians. any girl who romances girls, for that matter. it sounds shallow but in a world of hetmance and dead lesbians im starving

concepts are a big draw too - a very generic slice of life could have amazing characterisation, but i could never notice because the concept has nothing special. my favourite is probably when people take a common story and twist it, giving it a new lease of life (cough cartoony scifi vampires vs robot slayers cough) OR when it reminds me of stuff i really loved, that probably didnt do its concept justice. (like zildren reminds me of the sparticle mystery from cbbc)

Not many speech bubbles. clutched pages with more speech bubbles than art makes me think....why not just write a novel instead?
Some pages with lots of talking are acceptable but there is a limit.

I like a lot of mystery and spooky stuff. If weird stuff is going on, I am there! I also really like characters that have good, believable friendships with each other and work well together. Also, personal preference, not a fan of romance of any kind. It's boring to me. The chemistry either has to be really strong or it has to be reduced to an occasional subplot.

Also, if I feel like something is trying to pander to a demographic, I'm turned off from that too. I just want to see pure passion as far as the eye can see.

Hmmm...

A unique style, or at least super expressive faces.
Fairly simple and memorable character designs
Horror...usually.
Dark romance (that's not played as a GOOD romance)
Unique fantasy
Vampires....again, usually.
Stories set in past eras
Cyberpunk
Very interesting characters <--important.
Atmospheric settings/scenery...sucker for this. Like, if there's fog, the scenery pleases me. XD
The color blue-gray used in excess

Bright colors generally grab my interest, but clear and non-cluttered comics are what I really look for. Too much dialogue, bizarre paneling and whatnot will make it more difficult for me to read. I'm not a huge stickler on artwork as long as I can tell what's going on.

I really like a cartoony styles (as appose to anime and such). Especially ones that are unique and charming. Having unique characters is also good, which sort of has to do with both character design and art style.

I also like when the story is clear, both in writing and in readability (I can actually read your text and it is not too small or too cluttered). I like stories that rely more on visuals than on how much dialogue they can stuff in one panel.

When it comes to subject matter...anything about friendship and family. I also like racial diversity....mostly because my family is very racially diverse. I like stuff about class struggle and people struggling with emotions and such. I'm not to crazy about "emo" stuff, I prefer more realistic depictions of depression, not Hot Topic cliches.

dick jokes, full color, not anime or disney inspired art styles. Weird titles I suppose.

Good character designs are what draw me in initially. I mean, they gotta be at least decent if I have to look at them every page.

Then I have to see if the text is legible.

If those are a go then I'll read on to see if the story actually interests me.

I actually have to agree here, character design is something that I do enjoy in a series, which is one reason I have a hard time watching Mob Pyscho and other times it's just great. That's one of the reasons I put so much detail into the A.O.G Armors, I want them to look really cool, and even the non armored characters and demons I tried to make look pretty cool (Though sometimes "regular" street cloths are hard to think of).

As for the text in a story, as long as the story doesn't sound like it was written by a 6 yr old or a pre teen going through puberty (Too many innuendos) I'm fine with it, given that there is a story to begin with, I don't want something like Teen Titans Go or the rebooted Ben 10, that just drives me up the wall.